Archive for TV Shows

Culture Vulture: Best Films, TV, Streaming & Radio, 7–13 November 2026

Some weeks, television provides little more than a distraction. This week offers something better: programmes that revisit injustice, challenge powerful institutions and remind us that drama can sometimes change the way a country thinks.

My first pick is Mums v Big Pharma, on BBC Two on Monday at 9pm. It tells the extraordinary story of Emma Murphy and Janet Williams, two mothers who spent more than a decade fighting for justice over the sodium valproate scandal. Their campaign exposed the devastating consequences of prescribing the epilepsy medication during pregnancy and the failure to adequately warn families of the risks. An estimated 20,000 children in Britain were affected.

What makes their story so compelling is their refusal to be silenced. They encountered obstruction, disbelief and resistance from people and institutions that should have been listening. Yet they continued. There is something profoundly inspiring about ordinary people taking on powerful organisations and refusing to go away.

My second selection takes us back sixty years. Cathy Come Home, directed by Ken Loach and first broadcast in 1966, returns to BBC Four on Wednesday, accompanied by Loach’s own recollections of making it.

The importance of this television drama is difficult to overestimate. It follows an ordinary working-class family slipping into poverty and homelessness, exposing the insecurity that could destroy lives almost overnight. It helped force homelessness onto the national agenda. What is disturbing is how much of it remains relevant. Britain may have changed considerably since 1966, but the housing crisis certainly hasn’t disappeared.

My third pick is MOBO 30: Iconic Moments, on BBC One on Wednesday. The programme celebrates thirty years of the Music of Black Origin Awards and the extraordinary contribution of their founder, Kanya King, who died in June this year.

King’s achievement went far beyond organising an awards ceremony. She created a platform for musical talent that was too often ignored by the established industry. The resulting success helped transform British popular culture and contributed significantly to the growth of an internationally successful creative industry.

There is plenty else worth watching. A terrific collection of films ranges from the British gangster classic Brighton Rock to The Taking of Pelham One Two Three, while BBC Four devotes Friday evening to pioneering women in rock music. And for those who enjoy a little political dystopia, we have two very different instalments of The Hunger Games franchise.

Let’s see what’s on.


Saturday 7 November

8pm — Dune (2021), ITV2

Denis Villeneuve’s ambitious adaptation of Frank Herbert’s science-fiction novel takes us to Arrakis, a desert planet whose valuable resources are at the centre of a bitter struggle between competing dynasties.

Timothée Chalamet plays Paul Atreides, the young aristocrat drawn into a conflict involving imperial power, religious prophecy and colonial exploitation.

The spectacle is impressive, but Herbert’s political ideas are what make Dune particularly interesting. Beneath the spaceships and strange technology lies a story about control of resources, manufactured belief and the danger of charismatic leaders. It is science fiction with something substantial to say.

8.15pm — 40 TV Theme Tunes at the BBC, BBC Two

Catch up via BBC iPlayer.

A nostalgic journey through some of television’s most memorable theme music, featuring composers ranging from Irving Berlin to Ennio Morricone.

There are themes from MASH*, Minder, Brush Strokes, Crocodile Shoes and the delightful The Fall and Rise of Reginald Perrin, alongside music that became almost as famous as the programmes themselves.

Particular pleasures include Julee Cruise singing Falling, the haunting theme associated with Twin Peaks, and Clannad’s beautiful Theme from Harry’s Game.

Will Smith also makes an appearance with The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air.

A good television theme does something remarkable. In a few seconds, it establishes a mood and brings back an entire world of memories. Some are better remembered than the programmes they introduced.

9pm — The Taking of Pelham One Two Three (1974), 5 Action

One of the great underrated American thrillers.

Walter Matthau plays a New York transit official faced with a gang of armed criminals who have hijacked a subway train and are holding its passengers hostage. Robert Shaw is superb as the coldly calculating leader of the gang.

There is very little wasted in this film. The dialogue crackles, the characters are sharply drawn and the tension builds without resorting to the frantic editing that has become commonplace in modern action cinema.

Director Joseph Sargent makes excellent use of New York’s subway system, and David Shire’s brassy, jazz-influenced score is unforgettable.

It developed a cult following and influenced later hostage thrillers. The 2009 remake with Denzel Washington and John Travolta is respectable enough, but the original is much better. A small masterpiece of pacing and ensemble acting.

9.10pm — The Bride Wore Black (1968), BBC Four

François Truffaut’s stylish revenge thriller stars Jeanne Moreau as a woman methodically hunting down the men responsible for a tragedy that shattered her life. Inspired by Alfred Hitchcock, whom Truffaut greatly admired, the film combines suspense with a distinctly French interest in psychology, obsession and moral ambiguity.

Moreau is superb. Elegant, intelligent and faintly terrifying, she dominates every scene as a woman driven by grief but displaying very little outward emotion. Her calm determination is often more unsettling than anger would be.

Beautifully photographed and carefully constructed, The Bride Wore Black remains one of the most interesting films in Truffaut’s career. It lacks the reputation of Jules et Jim or The 400 Blows, but it deserves to be much better known. An excellent introduction to both Moreau and one of French cinema’s great directors.

10pm — The Grey (2011), ITV4

Liam Neeson stars in this bleak survival thriller about oil workers whose plane crashes in the Alaskan wilderness, leaving them struggling against freezing temperatures and a pack of wolves.

Neeson is especially effective as a man already burdened by despair before disaster strikes.

The film is less interested in conventional heroics than in mortality, fear and humanity’s uncomfortable relationship with nature. Its portrayal of wolf behaviour is dramatic rather than zoologically reliable, but the atmosphere of impending death is powerful.

10.55pm — Scene by Scene: Jeanne Moreau, BBC Four

An excellent companion to The Bride Wore Black.

Moreau was one of the defining faces of French cinema, associated particularly with the New Wave and directors including Louis Malle and François Truffaut.

Her performances combined intelligence, sensuality and independence, frequently challenging conventional representations of women on screen.

An opportunity to hear an important actress reflecting on her work and the development of modern cinema.

11.50pm — The Taste of Things (2023), BBC Two

A beautifully observed French period romance starring Juliette Binoche and Benoît Magimel.

Set in nineteenth-century France, it explores the relationship between a celebrated gourmet and the gifted cook with whom he has worked for many years.

Food is central to everything, but the film is about far more than cooking. Love, companionship, ageing and the pleasures of an ordinary shared life are explored with extraordinary tenderness.

The preparation of meals is filmed with such care that cooking becomes almost a form of choreography.

An unusually gentle and intelligent film.

12.05am — Rush (2013), BBC One

Ron Howard’s exciting account of the rivalry between Formula One drivers James Hunt and Niki Lauda during the 1976 season.

Chris Hemsworth captures Hunt’s flamboyance, while Daniel Brühl gives an excellent performance as the methodical, fiercely competitive Lauda.

The racing sequences are superb, but the real strength lies in the contrasting personalities of two men driven by the same ambition.

The film also conveys the extraordinary risks drivers accepted during an era when fatal accidents were an ever-present possibility.


Sunday 8 November

1.45pm — War Horse (2011), BBC One

Steven Spielberg’s adaptation of Michael Morpurgo’s novel follows a horse, Joey, from the English countryside into the horrors of the First World War.

It is occasionally sentimental, but Spielberg knows how to tell a story, and the film contains some remarkable scenes.

What I particularly appreciate is the way it crosses national boundaries. British and German soldiers are shown as human beings caught in a conflict far larger than themselves.

The suffering of the horses is another reminder of the appalling destruction caused by industrial warfare.

4.30pm — A Room with a View (1985), Film4

One of the great successes of British literary cinema.

James Ivory directs this adaptation of E. M. Forster’s novel, with Helena Bonham Carter as Lucy Honeychurch, a young Englishwoman whose experiences in Italy awaken feelings that conflict with the social expectations of Edwardian society.

The supporting cast is extraordinary, including Maggie Smith, Denholm Elliott, Judi Dench and Daniel Day-Lewis.

It is witty, beautifully photographed and quietly subversive in its treatment of class, convention and sexual repression.

5.30pm — Paths of Glory (1957), Great Action

Stanley Kubrick’s devastating anti-war film stars Kirk Douglas as a French officer defending soldiers selected for punishment after a disastrous military assault during the First World War.

Few films have exposed the cruelty and hypocrisy of military authority so effectively.

The generals responsible for impossible orders are protected by rank and privilege, while ordinary soldiers are expected to pay with their lives.

Kubrick’s direction is disciplined and unsentimental. The courtroom sequences are particularly powerful.

An essential film, and one that has lost none of its relevance.

9pm — Stacey Dooley’s Australia: Off the Beaten Track, Channel 4

Full series available on Channel 4 streaming.

Stacey Dooley travels beyond the familiar tourist images of Australia to explore its people, communities and landscapes.

Her informal interviewing style can be disarming, allowing people to speak about their experiences without the programme becoming overly formal.

An opportunity to see aspects of Australian life that rarely feature in conventional travel programmes.

9.50pm — Layer Cake (2004), Great Action

Daniel Craig plays an unnamed London cocaine dealer attempting to leave the criminal world behind, only to become entangled in an increasingly complicated series of betrayals.

Matthew Vaughn’s directorial debut is stylish, clever and very British in its cynicism.

The cast includes Michael Gambon, Colm Meaney and Sienna Miller.

Its depiction of organised crime is less romantic than it initially appears. Everyone is looking for an advantage, and loyalty is usually negotiable.

10.45pm — Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy (2011), BBC Two

Gary Oldman plays George Smiley in Tomas Alfredson’s atmospheric adaptation of John le Carré’s espionage novel.

Smiley is called out of retirement to identify a Soviet mole operating at the highest levels of British intelligence.

This is not a spy film built around car chases and explosions. Its world is one of quiet conversations, institutional rivalries, betrayal and exhausted men who have spent their lives deceiving others.

Oldman’s restrained performance is outstanding.

It also captures something important about the decline of British power and the moral ambiguities of the Cold War.

11.30pm — The Kitchen (2023), Channel 4

The Kitchen wears its politics on its sleeve, but that is not a criticism. Set in a near-future London where social housing has been systematically erased and whole communities have been pushed to the margins, the film imagines a Britain in which the gap between those who have and those who have not has become almost impossible to bridge. Co-directed by Daniel Kaluuya and Kibwe Tavares, it follows Izi, a young man desperate to leave the last remaining housing estate known as the Kitchen behind, only to find his plans complicated by his growing connection to a boy who has even less reason to believe the system will ever work in his favour.

At first glance, the story appears to be a piece of dystopian science fiction, but what gives it its power is the uncomfortable sense that very little of it feels far-fetched. The gleaming towers inhabited by the wealthy, the constant surveillance, the disappearance of affordable housing and the pressure placed on poorer communities to simply move elsewhere are all recognisable extensions of debates already taking place in British cities today. The film does not need flying cars or outlandish technology to make its point. The social realities it builds on are already visible.

The estate itself becomes the film’s most compelling character. Rather than depicting the Kitchen as a place of hopelessness, the directors present it as a community fighting to survive. Despite the poverty, the police attention and the political neglect, residents continue to support one another. The film is less concerned with the physical buildings than with what is lost when communities are broken apart in the name of regeneration and progress.

Visually, the production is striking. The futuristic elements are integrated into an environment that still feels recognisably London, creating a world that seems only a few steps beyond the present rather than existing in some distant fantasy. That realism strengthens the political message. The audience is never allowed the comfort of dismissing what they are seeing as pure fiction.

The Kitchen is ultimately a film about belonging, displacement and the value of community in an increasingly unequal society. Its arguments about gentrification, economic division and state power are direct and unapologetic, but they are grounded in human stories rather than political slogans. What lingers after the credits is not the dystopian setting itself, but the unsettling thought that the future it presents requires very little imagination. In many respects, the foundations are already here.

Cosmo Jarvis gives a remarkable performance as Douglas, a former boxer working as an enforcer for a criminal family in rural Ireland.

His loyalty is tested when he is ordered to commit an act of violence that threatens what remains of his moral independence.

Barry Keoghan is excellent in support.

A brutal, moving film about masculinity, exploitation and the difficulty of escaping a life shaped by violence.


Monday 9 November

4.35pm — Brighton Rock (1947), Talking Pictures TV

One of the most sinister gangster films ever made in Britain.

Adapted from Graham Greene’s novel, with Greene contributing to the screenplay, it follows Pinkie Brown, a vicious young criminal operating among the gangs and protection rackets of pre-war Brighton.

Richard Attenborough is extraordinary as Pinkie. His youthful appearance makes the character’s brutality even more disturbing. There is genuine menace beneath his carefully controlled exterior.

The film combines gangster conventions with Greene’s familiar preoccupations: Catholic guilt, sin, redemption and the possibility of damnation.

The Brighton locations add to its unsettling atmosphere. Behind the seaside amusements lies a world of intimidation, exploitation and murder.

A great British film, and one that deserves a much wider audience.

9pm — Mums v Big Pharma, BBC Two

One of my three picks of the week. Catch up via BBC iPlayer.

Emma Murphy and Janet Williams spent years campaigning to expose the devastating consequences of the sodium valproate scandal.

The medication, prescribed to treat epilepsy and certain other conditions, was associated with serious risks to babies exposed during pregnancy. Campaigners argued that families had not been adequately informed of those dangers.

Around 20,000 children in Britain are estimated to have been affected.

What follows is the story of two women who refused to accept official assurances and fought relentlessly for answers.

Their campaign encountered resistance from medical authorities, regulators and institutions that had a responsibility to protect patients.

The larger question is how such failures can continue for years while families struggle to make themselves heard.

This should be uncomfortable viewing for those who believe large institutions can always be trusted to investigate their own mistakes.

11pm — Mud (2012), BBC Two

Matthew McConaughey stars as a mysterious fugitive encountered by two boys on an island in the Mississippi River.

Director Jeff Nichols combines a coming-of-age story with elements of Southern Gothic and a romantic outlaw tale.

McConaughey is excellent, but the two young actors, Tye Sheridan and Jacob Lofland, are equally important.

The film is about youthful idealism confronting the complicated and frequently disappointing world of adults.

Warm, atmospheric and beautifully performed.

2.05am — The Future (2011), Film4

Miranda July’s peculiar and rather touching film follows a couple whose decision to adopt an injured cat causes them to reconsider almost every aspect of their lives.

The cat, Paw-Paw, narrates portions of the film, lending the story a strange mixture of innocence, sadness and philosophical reflection.

July is interested in the fear of commitment, the passing of time and the way people can become paralysed by imagined possibilities.

An unusual film that will certainly not appeal to everyone, but its originality is refreshing.


Tuesday 10 November

Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri (2017)

Channel and time to be confirmed.

Martin McDonagh’s powerful, darkly comic drama stars Frances McDormand as a mother who rents three roadside billboards to challenge the police over their failure to solve her daughter’s murder.

Woody Harrelson and Sam Rockwell are outstanding in support.

The film refuses easy moral distinctions. Its characters are angry, damaged, sometimes cruel and occasionally capable of unexpected kindness.

McDormand’s performance is magnificent. Her grief has hardened into a furious determination to confront authority.

There are uncomfortable questions here about racism, police misconduct, revenge and whether justice can ever repair the damage caused by violence.

10pm — Storyville: Manhood, BBC Four

Catch up via BBC iPlayer.

At first glance, a documentary about penis enlargement sounds like the sort of thing commissioned for shock value or cheap laughs. Storyville’s Manhood appears to take a more thoughtful route. The film follows Bill Moore, a Texas entrepreneur attempting to make penis enhancement as commonplace as Botox, alongside men willing to spend significant sums of money in pursuit of a larger penis and, they hope, greater confidence.

What emerges is less a story about physical appearance and more an examination of insecurity, self-image and the commercialisation of male anxieties. The men featured are not presented as figures of ridicule. Instead, the documentary explores why so many feel that changing their bodies might solve deeper problems relating to confidence, acceptance and self-worth. Critics have noted that the film treats its subjects with far more empathy than its subject matter might suggest.

The wider questions are difficult to ignore. In an age saturated with social media, influencer culture and endless pressure to optimise every aspect of life, men are increasingly targeted with products and procedures promising transformation. Whether those promises can ever deliver genuine happiness is another matter entirely.

Potentially awkward, occasionally amusing and quite possibly unsettling, this looks like one of those documentaries that starts with an eyebrow-raising premise before revealing something far more revealing about modern society.

Chloé Zhao’s remarkable film stars Frances McDormand as Fern, a woman who begins travelling across the American West in a van after losing her job and home.

Many of the people she encounters are real-life nomads playing versions of themselves.

The film is visually beautiful, but its underlying subject is economic insecurity. Older Americans who have worked all their lives find themselves unable to afford conventional housing or retirement.

There is freedom in Fern’s wandering existence, but there is also loss, loneliness and an economy that has abandoned many of its workers.

A compassionate and quietly political film.


Wednesday 11 November

7.30pm — The Future with Hannah Fry

Channel to be confirmed.

Mathematician Hannah Fry explores the technological and scientific developments likely to shape our lives.

Fry has a gift for making complex subjects understandable without talking down to her audience.

The most valuable programmes about the future are those that ask not simply what technology can accomplish, but who benefits from it and who might be left behind.

9pm — Murder in Belfast: Sisters Seeking Justice, BBC Two

Trial and Tribulation, the concluding episode of the three-part documentary.

The series examines the murder of Robert McCartney in Belfast in 2005 and the extraordinary campaign mounted by his sisters to uncover the truth.

McCartney’s death became politically significant because of allegations concerning republican involvement and attempts to obstruct the investigation.

His sisters refused to be intimidated or silenced.

It is an important story about family loyalty, the pursuit of justice and the difficulties of confronting powerful organisations in communities still affected by the legacy of Northern Ireland’s conflict.

10pm — Ken Loach Remembers: Cathy Come Home, BBC Four

Ken Loach during the ‘The Angel’s Share’ photocall during the 65th Cannes Film Festival, Cannes, France. 22/05/2012 Picture by: Henry Harris / Featureflash

One of my three picks of the week. Catch up via BBC iPlayer.

Ken Loach introduces his groundbreaking 1966 television drama and reflects on the circumstances in which it was made.

Written by Jeremy Sandford and produced by Tony Garnett, Cathy Come Home was one of the most important programmes in the history of British television.

10.15pm — Cathy Come Home (1966), BBC Four

Carol White stars as Cathy, a young woman whose marriage and family life unravel as unemployment, poverty and housing insecurity force them into increasingly desperate circumstances.

Its documentary-like realism made the drama especially shocking to contemporary audiences.

People were confronted with the reality that an ordinary family could lose everything through circumstances largely beyond their control.

The film helped transform public discussion of homelessness and became closely associated with the emergence of housing charities and campaigning organisations.

Sixty years later, it remains painfully relevant.

We still have working families struggling with unaffordable rents, insecure employment and the threat of homelessness.

There is a temptation to regard social dramas of this period as historical documents. Cathy Come Home is much more than that. It remains an indictment of a society that can allow vulnerable families to fall through the cracks.

10.40pm — MOBO 30: Iconic Moments, BBC One

My third pick of the week. Catch up via BBC iPlayer.

Thirty years after the first Music of Black Origin Awards in 1996, this programme looks back at some of the defining moments in the organisation’s history.

The death of its founder, Kanya King, in June makes the anniversary particularly poignant.

King created the MOBO Awards at a time when Black British musical achievement was not receiving the recognition it deserved.

But her vision extended beyond a single ceremony. She helped establish an organisation that became integral to the development of Black British popular culture.

The emergence of internationally successful British artists has been both a cultural achievement and an economic success, contributing to one of the country’s most valuable creative industries.

King understood that talent needed opportunity, recognition and institutional support.

An important British success story, and a fitting tribute to a remarkable entrepreneur.

11.35pm — Ken Loach in Conversation with Cillian Murphy, BBC Four

Following Cathy Come Home, Cillian Murphy discusses Loach’s long career exploring class, poverty, politics and social injustice.

Loach has spent decades examining lives that mainstream cinema frequently overlooks.

From Kes and Riff-Raff to I, Daniel Blake and The Old Oak, he has continued to give working-class experiences a central place in British filmmaking.

Whatever one’s politics, his contribution to cinema is immense.

12.40am — Slow West (2015), Film4

Michael Fassbender stars in this unusual Western about a young Scottish aristocrat travelling across the American frontier in search of the woman he loves.

He encounters a mysterious bounty hunter who offers to help him.

Director John Maclean approaches the Western with a mixture of dark humour, melancholy and sudden violence.

The film is visually striking and considerably more thoughtful than its modest running time might suggest.


Thursday 12 November

7.30pm — The Future with Hannah Fry, BBC Two

Full series available on BBC iPlayer.

This edition examines water scarcity, an increasingly serious problem affecting populations across the world.

Water is often taken for granted in countries such as Britain, yet climate change, population growth, pollution and ageing infrastructure are placing enormous pressure on supplies.

Technological solutions are important, but the question of ownership and access is equally significant.

Water is not an optional consumer product. It is essential to life, and its management raises fundamental questions about public responsibility.

8pm — Classic Movies: The Story of The Blue Angel, Sky Arts

A welcome edition of an interesting series examining celebrated films.

The Blue Angel, released in 1930, was directed by Josef von Sternberg and starred Emil Jannings and Marlene Dietrich.

Jannings plays a respectable schoolteacher whose obsession with a cabaret performer, played by Dietrich, destroys his professional standing and eventually his dignity.

The film helped establish Dietrich as an international star.

It also has a fascinating political history. Based on a novel by Heinrich Mann, it portrays authority as vulnerable, hypocritical and ultimately ridiculous.

Copies of the film were withdrawn from circulation in Nazi Germany in 1933. Its association with Mann, an outspoken opponent of Nazism, makes the censorship particularly revealing.

The idea of a schoolteacher being reduced to an object of public ridicule was hardly likely to appeal to an authoritarian movement concerned with obedience and established hierarchy.

A film with a remarkable history and well worth exploring.

9pm — The Hunger Games: Mockingjay – Part 1 (2014)

Channel to be confirmed.

Jennifer Lawrence returns as Katniss Everdeen, now transformed from a reluctant survivor into a symbol of rebellion against the authoritarian Capitol.

What makes The Hunger Games franchise so interesting is its understanding of propaganda.

Katniss becomes a political image, manipulated by the rebellion almost as carefully as she was previously manipulated by the regime.

The film asks uncomfortable questions about revolutionary leadership, media representation and the relationship between individuals and political movements.

It is easy to see why younger audiences responded so strongly to the series, but there is plenty here for older viewers too.

10pm — AI: Probably Nothing to Worry About, Channel 4

Catch up via Channel 4 streaming.

Artificial intelligence is developing at an extraordinary pace, and the public discussion often veers between technological utopianism and apocalyptic predictions.

The more immediate questions concern employment, surveillance, misinformation and the concentration of economic power.

Who owns the systems? Who controls the information? What happens to workers whose jobs are transformed or eliminated?

And who takes responsibility when automated decisions cause real harm?

Those are the questions worth asking, regardless of how reassuring or alarming the technology’s advocates may sound.

11pm — Hell or High Water (2016), BBC Two

Chris Pine and Ben Foster play brothers robbing banks across Texas, pursued by a veteran lawman played wonderfully by Jeff Bridges.

Director David Mackenzie turns what might have been a conventional crime thriller into a thoughtful examination of economic desperation.

The brothers are not simply criminals looking for easy money. Their actions emerge from a landscape of debt, foreclosure and communities left behind by economic change.

The film’s treatment of banks is particularly pointed.

It is intelligent, tense and occasionally very funny, with three excellent central performances.


Friday 13 November

7.30pm — Unreported World: Mexico’s Lost Boys, Channel 4

Catch up via Channel 4 streaming.

Guillermo Galdos reports from Ciudad Juárez, where families are battling to prevent children being drawn into the orbit of Mexico’s drug cartels. The programme examines claims that boys as young as 11 are being recruited by criminal organisations, while desperate parents turn to controversial and largely unregulated rehabilitation clinics in the hope of saving their sons before they become trapped in a cycle of violence and crime.

The story is ultimately about more than organised crime. It raises questions about poverty, family breakdown, state failure and the limited choices available to many young people growing up in communities where criminal groups can offer money, belonging and status that legitimate institutions struggle to provide. As ever with Unreported World, the value lies in hearing directly from those living through these realities rather than discussing them from a distance.

9.30pm — Girls in Bands at the BBC, BBC Four

Catch up via BBC iPlayer.

BBC Four devotes an evening to women who challenged the male dominance of the rock industry.

Archive performances provide an opportunity to celebrate not only famous performers but also musicians whose contribution has been neglected.

For much of rock history, women were expected to be singers or decorative additions to male bands. Women playing guitars, bass and drums in their own groups were often treated as novelties.

That attitude obscured some excellent musicians and important musical innovations.

This promises to be an enjoyable reminder of what those women achieved.

10.30pm — Siouxsie and the Banshees: Rock Goes to College, BBC Four

A performance recorded at Warwick University in 1981.

Siouxsie Sioux was one of the most striking figures to emerge from the British punk movement.

The Banshees moved beyond punk’s initial energy into something darker, more experimental and frequently more musically adventurous.

Their influence on post-punk, alternative rock and gothic music was considerable.

The Rock Goes to College series captured bands performing for relatively intimate audiences, and these recordings often have an immediacy absent from more elaborate concert productions.

11pm — Fanny: The Right to Rock, BBC Four

Rock history is full of stories about “forgotten pioneers”, but in Fanny’s case the description is justified. Formed around sisters June and Jean Millington, the band became the first all-female rock group to release an album on a major label. They wrote their own material, played their own instruments and built a formidable reputation as a live act, yet never achieved the lasting recognition their talent merited.

Part of the problem was timing. Fanny emerged at a moment when women in rock were still frequently treated as novelties rather than serious musicians. Reviews often focused on their appearance or gender rather than their songs. June and Jean Millington also faced the additional challenge of being among the very few Asian-American women visible in mainstream rock.

The quality of the music, however, was impossible to ignore. Fanny enjoyed chart success, toured extensively and earned the admiration of fellow musicians. David Bowie later described them as “one of the finest fucking rock bands of their time”, while lamenting how neglected they had become.

This documentary tells the story of a group that helped open doors for later generations of female musicians but rarely received the credit. If you’ve never heard of Fanny, that’s precisely why this programme matters. Their music deserves to be remembered, and their story deserves to be better known.

Frank Grillo stars in an entertaining science-fiction action thriller about a former soldier trapped in a time loop that repeatedly ends with his violent death.

Mel Gibson and Naomi Watts provide support.

The premise owes something to Groundhog Day, although the mood is considerably more violent.

It is energetic, inventive and frequently amusing, with some enjoyably absurd action sequences.

11.30pm — The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes (2023)

Channel to be confirmed.

This prequel explores the early life of Coriolanus Snow, long before he becomes the ruthless president familiar from the original Hunger Games films.

Tom Blyth plays the young Snow, while Rachel Zegler portrays Lucy Gray Baird, a tribute selected for the tenth Hunger Games.

I have long regarded The Hunger Games as one of the strongest young-adult dystopian franchises.

Its political and social ideas are unusually sophisticated for a series often marketed primarily at teenagers.

The films examine authoritarianism, social inequality, propaganda and the transformation of human suffering into mass entertainment.

Here we see how political ambition, personal insecurity and the desire for control contribute to the formation of a future dictator.

Viewed alongside Thursday’s Mockingjay – Part 1, it provides an interesting contrast between the origins of authoritarian power and the rebellion that eventually challenges it.

12.10am — This Is England (2006), Channel 4

Shane Meadows’ outstanding drama about a lonely young boy who becomes involved with a group of skinheads in 1983.

Thomas Turgoose is remarkable as Shaun, while Stephen Graham delivers a terrifying performance as Combo, a violent racist whose arrival transforms the group’s dynamics.

The film distinguishes between the multiracial roots of skinhead culture and the racist politics that sought to appropriate it.

It is also about unemployment, alienation, masculine insecurity and the social consequences of industrial decline.

Few British films of the past twenty years have captured the atmosphere of working-class England in the 1980s so convincingly.


Streaming Choices

Netflix

The Body — All eight episodes from Wednesday 11 November

A Halloween initiation ceremony involving a group of Catholic schoolgirls on a dance team goes disastrously wrong, unleashing disturbing visions, secrets and mass hysteria.

The premise combines adolescent rivalry, religious guilt and supernatural horror.

There is a long tradition of horror using teenage rituals as a way of exploring conformity, sexuality and the pressure to belong.

This looks like a promising addition to that tradition, particularly for those who enjoy psychologically unsettling drama rather than straightforward monsters and jump scares.

The Empress — Season 3, from Thursday 12 November

The lavish historical drama returns to the troubled marriage of Emperor Franz Joseph and Empress Elisabeth of Austria.

Franz returns traumatised by war, while political tensions place further pressure on the imperial marriage.

The appeal of The Empress lies partly in its elaborate costumes and production design, but the more interesting material concerns the restrictions imposed by aristocratic society and the conflict between personal freedom and dynastic duty.

Elisabeth remains a fascinating historical figure precisely because she struggled against the role assigned to her.


Channel 4 Streaming

Myth of the Zodiac Killer — Both episodes from Saturday 7 November

The Zodiac murders remain among America’s most notorious unsolved criminal cases.

This two-part documentary revisits the evidence surrounding the killer who terrorised Northern California in the late 1960s.

The case has generated endless speculation, partly because the murderer communicated with newspapers through letters and cryptic messages.

A worthwhile documentary needs to distinguish established evidence from the mythology built around the crimes.

True crime is most valuable when it examines investigative failures and the experiences of victims rather than turning murderers into celebrities.


ITVX

Scandal — Seasons 1–7 from Sunday 8 November

All seven seasons of Shonda Rhimes’ Washington political thriller become available.

Kerry Washington stars as Olivia Pope, a formidable political fixer whose clients include some of the most powerful figures in American public life.

The series combines melodrama, political intrigue and a deeply cynical view of the relationship between government, media and personal ambition.

It becomes increasingly extravagant as it progresses, but Washington’s charismatic performance holds the whole enterprise together.

Ideal for viewers looking for a long-running drama full of betrayal, conspiracy and political manipulation.


Disney+

Rivals — Series 2, episodes 7–9 from Wednesday 11 November

The adaptation of Jilly Cooper’s novel continues its gleeful exploration of ambition, sex, class and rivalry in the world of 1980s commercial television.

The attraction is the combination of outrageous behaviour and sharp observations about wealth, power and social climbing.

Cooper understood that the British class system could be both ridiculous and remarkably durable.

The television adaptation has considerable fun with that contradiction, helped by a cast clearly enjoying themselves.


Prime Video

The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power — Season 3, episodes 1–4, listed for Wednesday 11 November

Amazon’s ambitious fantasy series returns to the world of Middle-earth, exploring the struggles over power, allegiance and the growing influence of Sauron.

The series has divided admirers of Tolkien, particularly over its departures from the source material and its treatment of established characters.

Nevertheless, the scale of the production is impressive, and Tolkien’s underlying concerns remain powerful: the corrupting influence of power, the temptation of domination and the value of loyalty and sacrifice.

The season and release details require final confirmation before publication.

Tony — Available now

A documentary exploring the early life of Anthony Bourdain, the chef, writer and television personality who transformed food broadcasting.

Bourdain was very different from the conventional celebrity chef. He was outspoken, irreverent and interested in the lives of working people.

His programmes treated food as a route into culture, history and politics.

He was particularly good at allowing ordinary people to explain their own communities without the condescension that sometimes disfigures travel television.

An opportunity to discover more about the experiences that shaped him.


Dexter: Resurrection

Season 2, episode 3 — Listed for Friday 13 November

The darkly comic crime drama continues the story of Dexter Morgan, a serial killer whose relationship with violence and his own moral code has always been central to the franchise.

Michael C. Hall remains the principal attraction, bringing an unsettling mixture of charm, detachment and menace to the character.

The Dexter franchise has always played with the audience’s willingness to sympathise with someone whose actions should make sympathy almost impossible.

The precise season, episode and streaming availability still need checking.


Radio Highlights

Radio offers an unusually interesting collection this week, ranging from political protest and homelessness to Napoleon’s generals and the efforts of scientists to save Britain’s ash trees.

Saturday 7 November

8pm — Archive on 4: Still Reclaiming the Night, Radio 4

In 1977, during the period of fear generated by the Yorkshire Ripper murders, police advice in West Yorkshire effectively encouraged women to avoid going out alone at night.

Women responded with anger.

On 12 November 1977, the first British Reclaim the Night march took place in Leeds, challenging the assumption that women should restrict their movements because of the threat of male violence.

I remember the Reclaim the Night marches, and I always thought they represented a perfectly reasonable response to an unreasonable situation.

Why should women be expected to surrender their freedom of movement? Surely the responsibility of the police was to make the streets safer rather than advise half the population to stay at home.

The marches made that point forcefully.

There was controversy, certainly, but protest is sometimes necessary precisely because established institutions have failed to recognise the absurdity of their position.

An important piece of social history and a reminder that rights are often defended by people prepared to challenge conventional authority.

Sunday 8 November

7.15pm — Making Them Count, Radio 4

A programme exploring the work of London’s Museum of Homelessness.

The museum is an unusual institution because it seeks to preserve the experiences and histories of people who are frequently ignored or treated simply as a social problem.

Homelessness is too often discussed in terms of statistics, budgets and temporary accommodation figures.

Behind those numbers are individual lives, relationships, achievements and losses.

The programme also provides a connection with Wednesday’s screening of Cathy Come Home.

Sixty years after that drama shocked Britain, homelessness remains a major social issue. The museum’s work is therefore not simply historical. It is part of an ongoing argument about who deserves to be remembered and heard.

Monday 9 November

11.45am — Book of the Week: Napoleon and His Marshals, Radio 4

When Napoleon became Emperor of the French in 1804, he created a new military aristocracy by appointing eighteen Marshals of the Empire. Further appointments eventually brought the total to twenty-six.

Many had risen through the ranks during the Revolutionary Wars, their careers made possible by the destruction of the old aristocratic system.

Their stories are fascinating because their loyalties were never quite as straightforward as Napoleon might have wished.

Some became wealthy and powerful. Others remained devoted soldiers. A number grew increasingly disillusioned with the endless campaigns.

By the time of Waterloo, Napoleon’s relationship with many of his former commanders had broken down.

The changing loyalties of men such as Ney, Soult, Marmont and Bernadotte reveal much about ambition, political survival and the limits of personal loyalty.

An absorbing subject for anyone interested in European history.

Monday to Friday, 9.45pm — The Essay, Radio 3

A series of essays concerning the actor Ralph Fiennes and the craft of acting.

Fiennes is one of Britain’s most accomplished performers, equally comfortable in classical theatre and major cinema productions.

His career ranges from Shakespeare to Schindler’s List, The English Patient and the Harry Potter films.

The opportunity to reflect on acting as an art, rather than simply celebrity, is always welcome.

Tuesday 10 November

8.05am, 3.05pm and 11.05pm — People Fixing the World, BBC World Service

This edition looks at the development of new foods and the possibilities offered by scientific innovation.

Feeding a growing global population without exhausting natural resources presents enormous challenges.

New methods of food production may have a part to play, although questions of cost, nutrition, ownership and public acceptance are just as important as scientific feasibility.

The danger is that technological solutions become another means of concentrating control over the food supply in the hands of a few large corporations.

Innovation should benefit producers and consumers, not simply generate another profitable monopoly.

Wednesday 11 November

3.30pm — The Scientists Who Love Ash Trees, Radio 4

Ash trees growing along a dirt road on a sunny spring morning, Poland.

Britain’s ash trees are under threat from ash dieback, a fungal disease that has already caused enormous damage to woodlands and hedgerows.

The ash is deeply woven into British folklore.

Traditionally, it was associated with protection, healing and renewal. There were customs involving the sap of ash trees being given to babies, and sick children being passed through split ash trunks in the belief that the tree could help cure them.

These practices tell us something about the place trees occupied in the imagination of earlier generations, although they should not be confused with scientifically established medicine.

The modern scientific story is fascinating in its own right.

Researchers are studying the genetics of ash trees, looking particularly at those that show tolerance or resistance to ash dieback.

The hope is that understanding these differences will make it possible to protect surviving trees and develop more resilient future generations.

There is something rather moving about the combination of ancient affection for a familiar tree and the application of modern genetic science to help preserve it.

It would also be interesting to discover whether the ash’s reputation in folklore reflects particular properties of its wood, bark or leaves, or whether those traditions arose primarily from its place in everyday rural life.

Either way, saving the ash is a worthwhile endeavour.


Final Thoughts

What strikes me about this week’s choices is how many of them concern ordinary people confronting institutions and circumstances beyond their control.

The mothers fighting for justice in the sodium valproate scandal. The sisters seeking answers about Robert McCartney’s murder. The family in Cathy Come Home struggling against poverty and homelessness. Women marching through Leeds to assert their right to use public streets without fear.

Even the fictional worlds of The Hunger Games, Nomadland and Hell or High Water examine the relationship between power, inequality and personal freedom.

Not everything needs a political message, of course. Sometimes a beautifully made thriller, an entertaining comedy or an evening of good music is quite sufficient.

And there is plenty of that here too.

If I were choosing just three programmes, they would be Mums v Big Pharma, Cathy Come Home and MOBO 30: Iconic Moments.

But don’t overlook Brighton Rock, The Taking of Pelham One Two Three or Friday’s BBC Four celebration of women in rock. All deserve attention.

Enjoy your viewing and listening.

Patrick Harrington

 

 

Leave a Comment

The Mentalist: Seeing Red – Patrick Jane Meets His Match

The Mentalist – Season 1, Episode 7 (2008)

Spoilers ahead.

Patrick Jane is a fraud. Or at least he used to be. That’s something worth remembering when watching The Mentalist, because it’s easy to become so entertained by his cleverness that we overlook the rather unpleasant way he made his living before joining the California Bureau of Investigation.

He pretended to communicate with the dead. He took advantage of people’s grief, their hopes and their willingness to believe that somebody might possess knowledge beyond ordinary human understanding. He was extremely good at it, too. Then he made the catastrophic mistake of publicly mocking the serial killer Red John, who murdered his wife and daughter in retaliation.

We know this background from the beginning of the series. What makes Seeing Red, the seventh episode of the first season, interesting is that Jane comes face to face with somebody still practising his old profession.

Kristina Frye, played by Leslie Hope, is a psychic medium. She’s attractive, confident and knows precisely how to make people feel comfortable. Jane takes an immediate dislike to her. Actually, dislike hardly covers it. From their first meeting, he seems determined to demonstrate that she’s a charlatan.

He’s probably right. But his indignation is rather rich coming from a man who once did exactly the same thing.

The case begins with the murder of Rosemary Tennant, a wealthy widow deliberately run down by a car. She had recently consulted Frye, who claims to have warned her that danger was approaching. Naturally, this attracts Jane’s attention, although he’s more interested in exposing the psychic than entertaining any possibility of supernatural foresight.

I rather enjoy watching Jane dismantle the claims of professional mediums. Cold reading is a fascinating business. A few carefully chosen observations, some vague statements, a willingness to follow the subject’s reactions, and suddenly somebody appears to know things they couldn’t possibly have known. Add a grieving relative who desperately wants to believe, and the effect can be powerful.

I’ve never believed in the ability to contact the dead, although I understand why people might want to. Bereavement can leave even the most rational person longing for another conversation, another opportunity to say something left unsaid. There’s nothing foolish about that. The questionable part is charging people for the supposed privilege of providing it.

Frye is an interesting character because she doesn’t behave like an obvious con artist. She’s composed and apparently sympathetic. Leslie Hope wisely avoids turning her into some theatrical fortune-teller. Her Frye is a professional woman who seems genuinely convinced of her own importance, and perhaps of her powers.

Whether she actually believes in them is another matter.

Jane certainly doesn’t give her the benefit of the doubt. He needles her, questions her methods and plainly enjoys making her uncomfortable. At times, his behaviour borders on bullying. His past explains some of that hostility, but I suspect there’s professional pride involved as well. He doesn’t simply want to prove she’s wrong. He wants to prove he’s cleverer.

One of the pleasures of the series is watching Teresa Lisbon attempt to keep Jane under some sort of control. Robin Tunney has a difficult job playing the sensible one, the person who has to worry about evidence, procedure and whether Jane’s latest performance is going to wreck a perfectly good investigation.

It’s not always a glamorous role, but Tunney makes her convincing. Lisbon doesn’t have Jane’s extraordinary powers of observation, yet she possesses something he frequently lacks: sound judgement.

She also recognises that his dispute with Frye is becoming personal. Jane may insist that he’s exposing a fraud, but he’s allowing his feelings to interfere with a murder investigation. Lisbon, quite reasonably, would prefer him to concentrate on finding the killer.

Meanwhile, the investigation moves into Rosemary Tennant’s complicated family affairs. Her children, Clara and Travis, have their own problems, and tensions over money and Rosemary’s behaviour provide possible motives. There are questions about her will, relationships within the family and the extent to which Frye may have influenced her decisions.

It’s the sort of domestic unpleasantness that often lies behind apparently mysterious deaths. Families can be extraordinarily vicious towards one another, particularly when money, disappointment and years of accumulated resentment become entangled.

The eventual revelation that Clara killed her mother is not particularly shocking, although the circumstances are more interesting than a straightforward inheritance killing. Clara’s anger and her feelings about her mother’s treatment of Travis are central to what happened.

What I found more entertaining was Jane’s method of exposing her.

Having spent much of the episode attacking Frye’s supposed supernatural abilities, he stages a séance of his own. It’s an elaborate performance designed to put pressure on the murderer and provoke a revealing reaction.

So there we have it. The man who despises fraudulent mediums employs their methods when it suits him.

Jane would undoubtedly argue that the difference lies in his intentions. He wants to establish the truth, whereas Frye claims to possess supernatural knowledge. Fair enough. But it doesn’t alter the fact that he is manipulating people’s emotions to achieve his purpose.

I’m not entirely convinced some of Jane’s methods would survive serious scrutiny in a real investigation. His elaborate tricks are entertaining television, but they sometimes depend on suspects behaving exactly as he expects. Human beings are rarely so obliging.

Still, that’s part of the pleasure of The Mentalist. It’s not a documentary about police procedure. We watch because Jane has a gift for noticing the small things everybody else overlooks, and because Simon Baker makes the character so enjoyable even when he’s being thoroughly objectionable.

Baker is particularly good in this episode. He can make Jane’s contempt apparent with little more than a smile or a raised eyebrow. His usual relaxed manner, lounging on furniture and drinking tea while everybody else works, disguises a much harder personality. When Frye challenges him, that side comes to the surface.

There’s an interesting moral question here, although I don’t think the programme needs to labour it. Jane knows how easily hope can be exploited, yet he sometimes seems more interested in humiliating the supposed psychic than protecting the people being deceived.

There’s a difference between challenging dishonesty and mocking the vulnerable. It’s one he doesn’t always recognise.

His own tragedy gives him every reason to feel bitter, but it doesn’t excuse everything he does. I like that about the character. He’s neither a conventional television hero nor a reformed sinner who has suddenly acquired perfect judgement. He’s capable of genuine kindness and considerable insensitivity, sometimes within the same conversation.

Seeing Red is not the strongest murder mystery of the first season. The case is serviceable rather than exceptional, and the final revelation doesn’t carry quite the impact the writers might have intended. But I enjoyed the episode because of the tension between Jane and Frye.

Leslie Hope makes her a credible opponent. She doesn’t appear intimidated by Jane, and there’s a certain amusement in watching somebody who is accustomed to controlling every conversation discover that another person can play the same game.

I also like the fact that the programme doesn’t entirely settle the question of Frye’s sincerity. Jane is certain she’s a fraud. As viewers, we’re entitled to agree with his scepticism while still wondering whether she has managed to deceive herself as successfully as she deceives others.

That possibility is more interesting than presenting her as an obvious crook. People can be remarkably talented at convincing themselves of things they want to believe, particularly when those beliefs also provide a comfortable living.

By the end, the murderer has been identified and the investigation completed. Jane has demonstrated his cleverness once again. Nothing unusual there.

But Kristina Frye has left him uncomfortable, and I suspect that’s because she reminds him of a past he would prefer to put behind him.

He may have given up pretending to speak to the dead. He hasn’t given up playing games with the living.

And I suspect he never will.

By Chris Storton

Leave a Comment

Culture Vulture Halloween Selection 2026

Welcome to Culture Vulture, and a special Halloween edition for the week of 31 October to 6 November 2026.

I’ve always enjoyed a good horror film, although the best ones offer rather more than blood, screams and an unfortunate teenager opening the wrong door.

Horror can expose our fears, our prejudices, and the darker side of perfectly ordinary people.

This week, we’ve got an excellent selection of films and programmes. So, dim the lights, and let’s begin.

First, John Carpenter’s The Fog, showing on Sky Arts at nine on Halloween night.

A small Californian town is preparing to celebrate its centenary. Unfortunately, its prosperity was founded upon a terrible betrayal, and the dead are returning to settle the account.

They come concealed in a luminous fog that rolls towards the shore.

Carpenter understood that anticipation can be far more frightening than spectacle. A lighthouse, an isolated radio station and a street disappearing into mist become instruments of terror.

We know something is approaching, but we can’t quite see it.

Underneath this beautifully constructed ghost story is a sharp idea: respectable communities often prefer to forget the injustices upon which their comfort was built.

The victims, it seems, have rather longer memories.

Next, Ghostwatch: The Night That Terrified Britain, on Channel 5 at quarter past nine.

In 1992, the BBC broadcast what appeared to be a live investigation into a haunted house.

Michael Parkinson and Sarah Greene were among the familiar presenters. That was the trick.

Viewers knew these people and trusted the BBC, so the increasingly bizarre events seemed alarmingly credible.

Ghostwatch was fiction, but some people believed they were watching real supernatural activity.

This retrospective explores the controversy and the cleverness of the original production.

It’s also remarkably relevant today. When something arrives in the familiar clothing of news or documentary, we may accept it rather too readily.

Ghostwatch knew that long before social media.

Film4 has Talk to Me at ten o’clock.

This Australian horror begins with a wonderfully unpleasant object: an embalmed hand which allows a group of teenagers to contact the dead.

Rather than treating this discovery with caution, they turn it into a party game.

There’s something horribly convincing about that. The séances are filmed, shared and repeated, until the desire to impress friends becomes more important than common sense.

But the film isn’t merely sneering at teenage foolishness.

Beneath its increasingly disturbing events is a serious story about grief, isolation and the need to feel connected to somebody.

I like horror that makes its violence matter.

Here, terrible choices have physical and emotional consequences.

It’s unsettling, sometimes brutal, and more intelligent than the premise initially suggests.

At ten forty-five, Sky Arts offers The Life and Deaths of Christopher Lee.

Lee remains one of my favourite British actors.

His extraordinary height, commanding voice and ability to communicate menace with the slightest movement made him unforgettable as Dracula.

But I think the success of that role sometimes obscured how versatile he really was.

Consider The Wicker Man, The Lord of the Rings, and Star Wars.

These aren’t simply different costumes for the same Gothic monster. Lee could suggest intelligence, authority, humour and even vulnerability.

He was a genuinely impressive performer who sometimes had to fight against his own legend.

This documentary should be a welcome reminder that an actor’s most famous role isn’t necessarily the measure of his entire career.

That leads naturally to Hammer: Heroes, Legends and Monsters, available on Prime Video.

Hammer transformed British horror cinema, bringing colour, sensuality and a distinctly Gothic extravagance to stories critics often dismissed as cheap thrills.

Christopher Lee and Peter Cushing became international stars, but the studio’s influence went well beyond its leading actors.

Its costumes, sets, atmosphere and willingness to disturb the supposedly respectable made a lasting impression.

There’s a certain pleasure in watching the films today: they’re imaginative, unmistakably British, and often far more sophisticated than their reputation suggests.

Staying with Christopher Lee, The Wicker Man is available on BBC iPlayer until Sunday 1 November.

If you haven’t seen the original 1973 film, make it a priority.

A devout Christian policeman travels to a remote Scottish island to investigate the disappearance of a girl.

What he finds is a community whose beliefs and customs are unlike anything he expects.

Lee plays Lord Summerisle, the island’s charismatic leader, with wonderful assurance.

What makes this folk horror so fascinating isn’t simply its increasingly sinister atmosphere.

It’s the confrontation between people absolutely convinced that their own beliefs are right.

Neither side finds much room for doubt, let alone compromise.

And that certainty takes the story somewhere truly disturbing.

It’s a remarkable film, with a conclusion that stays with you.

On Thursday, BBC Four is showing Carrie, Brian De Palma’s 1976 adaptation of Stephen King’s novel.

Sissy Spacek plays Carrie White, an isolated schoolgirl bullied by her classmates and terrorised at home by her fanatically religious mother.

She also possesses telekinetic powers, but those powers aren’t where the horror really begins.

It’s in the humiliation, the everyday cruelty, and the appalling lack of kindness shown towards somebody already vulnerable.

De Palma’s direction is extravagant and often dazzling. The famous school prom is still a masterclass in mounting tension.

Yet Carrie remains painfully sympathetic even as the consequences become terrifying.

That’s the film’s real achievement.

It reminds us that some monsters don’t have supernatural powers.

They’re perfectly ordinary people, behaving with extraordinary cruelty.

Immediately afterwards, Mark Lawson talks to Stephen King about his writing and career.

King’s enormous popularity has sometimes made literary critics rather sniffy about him.

I think that’s a mistake.

Few contemporary writers are better at portraying ordinary communities in which something is deeply wrong.

The supernatural often provides the occasion for the story, but the real subject is human weakness, fear or cruelty.

And he’s hardly confined to horror.

Think of Stand by Me and The Shawshank Redemption.

King understands people, which is why his stories survive beyond the initial shock.

For something gentler, although still wonderfully Gothic, ITV2 has Edward Scissorhands on Saturday afternoon.

Johnny Depp plays an artificial young man left unfinished by his inventor, with scissors where his hands ought to be.

A suburban neighbourhood welcomes him as a curiosity, then gradually turns against him when novelty gives way to suspicion.

Tim Burton creates a beautiful contrast between Edward’s strange appearance and the colourful conformity of the people around him.

Danny Elfman’s score makes it especially moving.

Beneath the fantasy is a rather sad truth: being different can make you an easy target, even when you’ve done nothing wrong.

Sky Documentaries has Boorman and the Devil at eight on Saturday, examining John Boorman’s notorious Exorcist sequel.

Now, Boorman was no incompetent.

He made Point Blank, Deliverance and Excalibur.

So how did such a talented filmmaker become involved in one of horror cinema’s most spectacular misjudgements?

I rather enjoy documentaries about artistic disasters.

They show how ambition, money and strong personalities can produce results nobody intended.

A failed film can be almost as revealing as a masterpiece, sometimes more so.

There is a radio treat, too.

At eight on Halloween night, Magic Classical presents Soundtracking: Horror with Ayanna Witter-Johnson.

Consider how much of the terror in Psycho, Halloween or The Exorcist comes from what we hear rather than what we see.

A few notes can warn us that something dreadful is coming, or lull us into a false sense of security.

Music plays with expectation, often more effectively than elaborate special effects.

Sometimes the scariest part of a film is the soundtrack.

On Friday, Talking Pictures TV has Brian De Palma’s Body Double.

It’s a lurid thriller about a struggling actor whose habit of spying on a woman leads him into a murder mystery.

De Palma plays with voyeurism and the uneasy relationship between looking and knowing.

The film is deliberately provocative, and its treatment of women remains controversial.

But as an exercise in manipulating the audience, it’s certainly distinctive.

Not subtle, perhaps, but never dull.

And on Paramount+, Dexter: Resurrection continues the story of television’s most unsettling vigilante killer.

Michael C. Hall remains compelling as Dexter Morgan, a man whose crimes we’re repeatedly invited to excuse because some of his victims are worse than he is.

It’s a clever moral trap.

How much violence will audiences tolerate when they believe the target deserves it?

After so many years, that uncomfortable question still gives the character much of his fascination.

So that’s our Halloween selection: ghosts, Gothic monsters, human cruelty, dark humour and a few genuine cinematic classics.

What the best horror films share is the power to make us think as well as shiver.

Until next time, happy Halloween, and pleasant nightmares.

Leave a Comment

Culture Vulture | 31 October – 6 November 2026: 90 Years of Television, Halloween Horrors and Cinematic Masterpieces

Ninety years ago, on 2 November 1936, something remarkable happened at Alexandra Palace in London. The BBC began the world’s first regular high-definition television service, although what passed for high definition then would barely register as a picture today. There were no video recordings, precious few viewers and two competing technologies battling to shape the future. Nobody could have imagined quite how profoundly that strange new box would transform our lives. BBC Four marks the anniversary with an evening of archive programmes, and it’s one of my highlights of the week.

We’re also celebrating Halloween, with a particularly strong collection of horror films and documentaries. There’s the chilling supernatural atmosphere of The Fog, the infamous television hoax Ghostwatch, Brian De Palma’s Carrie, and a chance to reconsider Christopher Lee, an actor whose magnificent portrayal of Dracula brought him worldwide fame but arguably denied him the recognition his wider talents deserved.

My third highlight is one of my favourite films, Carol Reed’s Odd Man Out (1947), starring James Mason. It’s a masterpiece of British cinema, a bleak, atmospheric and deeply human story set against the political tensions of Northern Ireland. Elsewhere, there’s Ingmar Bergman, Jane Austen, artificial intelligence, the struggle for women’s rights, Muhammad Ali and a welcome double helping of The Hunger Games, which I regard as one of the finest dystopian science-fiction film series aimed at younger audiences ever made.

As usual, there are excellent programmes tucked away in the schedules, sometimes at quite unreasonable hours. Here are my selections for the coming week.

Saturday 31 October 2026

Odette (1950) 10.30 am – BBC Two

Anna Neagle stars as Odette Sansom, the remarkable British-based French secret agent who worked with the Special Operations Executive during the Second World War. Captured by the Germans, she endured imprisonment and torture before surviving the war.

The film was made just five years after the conflict ended, when the events it depicted were still painfully fresh. That gives it an immediacy quite different from later wartime dramas.

There is an old-fashioned restraint about its presentation, but the underlying story is extraordinary. At its heart is a woman whose courage was demonstrated not through grand gestures but through her refusal to betray others, even under appalling pressure.

Sense and Sensibility (1995) 1.25 pm – BBC Two

Ang Lee’s adaptation of Jane Austen’s novel is one of the finest examples of literary cinema from the 1990s. Emma Thompson and Kate Winslet play the contrasting Dashwood sisters, navigating love, money and the suffocating expectations of polite society.

Thompson’s screenplay is wonderfully intelligent, preserving Austen’s wit while making the emotional dilemmas accessible to modern audiences. Alan Rickman and Hugh Grant contribute memorable performances.

Beneath the elegant costumes and romantic entanglements lies something sharper: a society in which women’s economic security depends heavily upon marriage. Austen understood the cruelty of that arrangement, and this beautiful adaptation never quite lets us forget it.

Edward Scissorhands (1990) 5.55 pm – ITV2

Tim Burton’s strange and touching modern fairy tale stars Johnny Depp as an artificial young man whose inventor died before completing him, leaving him with scissors instead of hands.

Taken into a brightly coloured suburban community, Edward initially becomes a curiosity and something of a local celebrity. But public fascination gradually turns into suspicion and hostility.

Burton’s sympathies are unmistakably with the outsider. Beneath the Gothic imagery and eccentric comedy lies a moving story about conformity, cruelty and society’s inability to accept difference. Danny Elfman’s haunting musical score makes it even more memorable.

Boorman and the Devil (2026) 8.00 pm – Sky Documentaries

John Boorman’s Exorcist II: The Heretic (1977) has a reputation as one of cinema’s most spectacular failures. This documentary examines how an ambitious filmmaker came to direct a sequel to one of the most influential horror films ever made, and why things went so disastrously wrong.

There’s something rather enjoyable about documentaries examining cinematic catastrophes. Failure can sometimes reveal more about the filmmaking process than success, particularly when powerful personalities, artistic ambition and commercial expectations collide.

Boorman was no incompetent. He made Point Blank, Deliverance and Excalibur. That’s what makes the story so interesting. Even immensely talented directors can make extraordinary misjudgements, and yesterday’s disaster can become today’s fascinating cinematic curiosity.

The Fog (1980) 9.00 pm – Sky Arts

John Carpenter’s atmospheric supernatural horror concerns a coastal Californian community visited by a mysterious fog carrying the ghosts of drowned mariners. As an old injustice returns to haunt the living, the town’s carefully maintained sense of security begins to unravel.

Carpenter understood that horror often works best through anticipation. The approaching fog, the isolated lighthouse and the ominous radio broadcasts create a sense of dread long before the supernatural threat becomes visible.

It’s an excellent Halloween selection. Beneath the ghost story lies a familiar but effective theme: communities sometimes build their prosperity upon crimes they would prefer to forget.

Ghostwatch: The Night That Terrified Britain 9.15 pm – Channel 5

In 1992 the BBC broadcast Ghostwatch, a fictional investigation into a supposedly haunted house presented in the style of live television. Familiar broadcasters, including Michael Parkinson and Sarah Greene, helped give the production an unsettling appearance of authenticity.

Millions watched, and some viewers reportedly believed they were witnessing genuine supernatural events. The programme became one of the most controversial television experiments of its era.

This retrospective explores how the hoax worked and why it provoked such an extraordinary reaction. It’s also a fascinating reminder of a time when familiar television personalities and the BBC’s institutional authority could make an invented story seem alarmingly real.

Fanny and Alexander (1982) 9.20 pm – BBC Four

Ingmar Bergman’s extraordinary family saga is among the great achievements of European cinema. Seen largely through the eyes of two children, it begins in the warmth and theatrical splendour of a prosperous Swedish household before moving into darker territory.

Bergman contrasts a world of imagination, sensuality and artistic freedom with the cold authoritarianism of an austere religious household. The children find themselves confronting an adult world whose moral certainties can conceal extraordinary cruelty.

It’s a long and demanding work, but also surprisingly accessible, full of humour, warmth, mystery and unforgettable images. Bergman understood how childhood experiences shape our understanding of power, love and fear. Few directors have explored those themes with greater sophistication.

Talk to Me (2022) 10.00 pm – Film4

This Australian supernatural horror follows a group of teenagers who discover that an embalmed hand allows them to communicate with the dead. Naturally, what begins as a thrilling party trick quickly becomes something considerably more dangerous.

The cleverness lies in how convincingly the filmmakers portray youthful recklessness. Contacting spirits becomes a social activity, something to film, share and compete over. It’s almost a supernatural version of the pressures created by social media.

Beneath the shocks is a serious exploration of grief, addiction and vulnerability. The violence is disturbing, but it has consequences, and the film is considerably more emotionally intelligent than its premise might suggest.

The Life and Deaths of Christopher Lee 10.45 pm – Sky Arts

Christopher Lee possessed one of cinema’s most extraordinary faces and voices. Tall, commanding and capable of projecting menace with the slightest movement, he became internationally famous for playing Dracula in Hammer’s Gothic horror films.

Yet Lee was far more versatile than his reputation suggested. His career encompassed historical drama, thrillers, fantasy and memorable appearances in The Wicker Man, The Lord of the Rings and Star Wars. He understood the opportunities horror offered, but also resented being reduced to a succession of monsters.

I have always thought Lee was an underestimated actor, perhaps a victim of his own success. Dracula made him a star, but the role sometimes obscured his range. This documentary should make an excellent companion to Hammer: Heroes, Legends and Monsters, also available on Prime Video.

The Iron Claw (2023) 11.55 pm – BBC One

Sean Durkin’s powerful drama tells the tragic story of the Von Erich wrestling family, whose apparently glamorous success concealed a succession of devastating personal tragedies.

Zac Efron gives an impressively restrained performance as Kevin Von Erich, one of several brothers raised under the relentless expectations of their father. Professional wrestling provides the spectacle, but the real drama concerns masculinity, family obligation and the pressure to achieve.

What makes the film so affecting is its depiction of people who genuinely love one another yet remain trapped within destructive expectations. It’s a heartbreaking story, made more disturbing by its basis in real events.

Arena: Bergman and Faro Island 12.20 am – BBC Four

Following Fanny and Alexander, this documentary offers an intimate encounter with Ingmar Bergman on the Swedish island of Fårö, which became both his home and a central part of his creative world.

Bergman reflects upon his childhood, his artistic influences and the personal anxieties that repeatedly surfaced in his films. His work can seem forbiddingly intellectual, but his recurring concerns are recognisably human: loneliness, faith, love, mortality and the difficulty of understanding other people.

It’s a particularly satisfying companion to the earlier film.

Sunday 1 November 2026

Kevin McCloud’s Classic Car Road Trips – Episode 3 of 6 8.00 pm – Channel 4

Kevin McCloud travels around Northern Ireland in the DeLorean DMC-12, one of the most instantly recognisable cars in motoring history, thanks largely to its starring role in Back to the Future.

But the DeLorean’s real history is arguably as remarkable as its fictional adventures. Built near Belfast, it represented ambitious industrial hopes during a period of extraordinary political and economic difficulty. Its spectacular collapse left behind broken promises, lost jobs and a car that became a cultural icon.

For me, that industrial story is just as interesting as the motoring nostalgia. It’s a reminder of how much can be invested in ambitious manufacturing projects, and how devastating their failure can be for the workers and communities involved.

The Creator (2023) 9.00 pm – Film4

Gareth Edwards directs this visually ambitious science-fiction drama set during a future conflict between humanity and artificial intelligence. John David Washington plays a former soldier drawn into a mission involving a mysterious robotic child whose existence may alter the course of the war.

What impressed me most about The Creator was not its plot, which sometimes struggles under the weight of its own ideas, but its extraordinary visual imagination. Edwards creates a future that feels inhabited rather than manufactured, a world where advanced technology sits alongside ordinary communities and familiar human concerns. Too much modern science fiction mistakes spectacle for imagination. This film largely avoids that trap.

Its politics are perhaps more interesting than its storytelling. The film invites us to consider how easily societies define entire groups as threats and then justify almost unlimited violence against them. Whether every aspect of that argument stands up to scrutiny is debatable, but the questions remain worthwhile. Flawed, certainly, but far more ambitious than most contemporary blockbuster science fiction.

Walk the Line (2005) 10.45 pm – BBC Two

Joaquin Phoenix and Reese Witherspoon give excellent performances in this account of Johnny Cash’s rise to fame, personal struggles and relationship with June Carter.

Like most musical biographies, Walk the Line simplifies a complicated life. Nevertheless, it captures something essential about Cash himself. He was one of those rare performers who seemed able to speak simultaneously to devout Christians, social outsiders, working-class audiences and cultural rebels. His music carried a mixture of faith, guilt, compassion and defiance that was uniquely his own.

The film understands that Cash’s appeal was never simply musical. He represented a particular vision of America: flawed, restless, deeply religious, suspicious of authority and permanently searching for redemption. Phoenix may not look exactly like Cash, but he captures that spirit remarkably well.

Ex Machina (2014) 11.40 pm – Film4

Alex Garland’s intelligent, unsettling science-fiction drama follows a young programmer invited to assess whether an advanced humanoid robot possesses genuine consciousness.

Alicia Vikander is extraordinary as Ava, a machine whose apparent vulnerability and intelligence may conceal motives neither the programmer nor his employer fully understands.

The film asks difficult questions about artificial intelligence, manipulation, sexual objectification and power. Its central insight is that the ability to appear human may be quite different from being human. With AI increasingly entering our everyday lives, those questions have become even more relevant.

Plan B (2021) 12.15 am – E4

Natalie Morales directs this American comedy about two teenage friends who embark on a desperate road trip to obtain emergency contraception after an unfortunate sexual encounter.

Its humour can be outrageous, but the subject is serious. Beneath the comic mishaps lies a story about young women’s access to reproductive healthcare and the obstacles placed in their way.

The film benefits from treating its teenage protagonists as recognisable young people rather than simply using them as vehicles for embarrassing jokes. It’s funny, politically aware and unexpectedly warm-hearted.

I’m Your Man (2021) 1.50 am – Film4

Maria Schrader’s thoughtful German romantic comedy stars Maren Eggert as a scientist persuaded to spend several weeks with a humanoid robot, played by Dan Stevens, programmed to become her ideal romantic partner.

What initially seems like an amusing science-fiction premise gradually develops into something more philosophical. Can a relationship be meaningful if one participant has been designed entirely around the other’s desires?

It’s a subtle and often touching film about loneliness, emotional expectations and the uncomfortable possibility that perfect compatibility might not be what human beings actually need.

Monday 2 November 2026

Concorde: The Untold Story – Part 1 of 2 8.40 pm – PBS America

The extraordinary story of Concorde, the Anglo-French supersonic airliner that became a symbol of technological ambition and national prestige.

Concorde represented an era when Britain and France were prepared to invest in engineering projects on a genuinely extraordinary scale. It was expensive, commercially difficult and ultimately available only to a privileged few, but its technical achievements remain impressive.

For anyone interested in British industry and the history of aviation, this should be fascinating.

Rise of the Planet of the Apes (2011) 9.00 pm – Film4

Rupert Wyatt’s intelligent reboot of the famous science-fiction series explores the origins of a world in which genetically enhanced apes challenge human domination.

Andy Serkis’s performance as Caesar is one of the great achievements of motion-capture acting. The character’s growing intelligence and awareness are conveyed with remarkable emotional subtlety.

Beneath the action lies a story about animal experimentation, exploitation and the consequences of treating other intelligent beings as property. Like the best science fiction, it holds up an uncomfortable mirror to human society.

Escaping Idi Amin – Part 2 of 2  9.00 pm – BBC Two. Catch up via BBC iPlayer.

In 1972, Ugandan dictator Idi Amin ordered the expulsion of tens of thousands of people of Asian descent, destroying established communities and forcing families to abandon homes and livelihoods.

This documentary uses the memories of a man who experienced those events as a boy. The child’s perspective makes the history particularly affecting, bringing the fear, uncertainty and bewilderment of forced displacement into sharp focus.

It’s also a reminder of how rapidly political demagoguery can turn neighbours into supposed enemies, with devastating human consequences.

Trauma: My Broken Brain 10.00 pm – Channel 4. Catch up via Channel 4 streaming.

A documentary exploring the consequences of serious brain trauma and the difficult process of rebuilding a life afterwards.

Brain injuries can alter memory, personality, relationships and independence in ways that outsiders struggle to appreciate. Recovery is seldom straightforward, and families may find themselves adapting to circumstances that neither they nor the injured person could have anticipated.

Programmes like this are valuable precisely because they illuminate experiences that often remain invisible.

Dispatches: The Taliban’s War on Women 11.00 pm – Channel 4. Catch up via Channel 4 streaming.

The Taliban’s treatment of women and girls in Afghanistan represents one of the most systematic assaults on women’s freedom in the modern world.

Restrictions on education, employment, movement and public participation have stripped women of rights that should be regarded as fundamental. This documentary examines the human consequences of those policies.

It’s essential viewing, not least because international attention has too often moved elsewhere while Afghan women continue to face extraordinary repression.

Fallen Leaves (2023) Midnight – BBC Two

Finnish director Aki Kaurismäki offers a wonderfully understated story about two lonely working-class people whose paths cross in contemporary Helsinki.

Kaurismäki’s films are immediately recognisable: sparse dialogue, carefully composed images, dry humour and characters who rarely express more than absolutely necessary.

Yet beneath the deadpan surface lies considerable tenderness. This is a film about economic insecurity, loneliness and the possibility of finding happiness in unpromising circumstances. Quiet, humane and rather beautiful.

Tuesday 3 November 2026

Suffragette (2015) 6.40 pm – Film4

Sarah Gavron’s historical drama explores the campaign for women’s voting rights in Britain, concentrating on working-class women whose contributions are sometimes overshadowed by those of more prominent campaigners.

Carey Mulligan plays a laundry worker whose involvement in the suffragette movement places her job, family and personal security at risk. The film is particularly effective in depicting the economic vulnerability of women who dared to challenge established authority.

The struggle for democratic rights was not a polite exercise in persuasion. Campaigners faced imprisonment, violence, forced feeding and the loss of their livelihoods. It’s an important reminder that rights now taken for granted were won through organisation, sacrifice and direct confrontation with entrenched power.

D. H. Lawrence: Sex, Exile and Greatness 8.00 pm – Sky Arts

D. H. Lawrence remains one of Britain’s most fascinating and controversial writers. Born into a working-class Nottinghamshire family, he challenged prevailing attitudes towards class, sexuality, religion and industrial society.

His novels, including Sons and Lovers, Women in Love and Lady Chatterley’s Lover, explored the conflict between emotional freedom and the social conventions that constrain it.

Lawrence was frequently contradictory, sometimes infuriating, but never dull. His insistence that sexual and emotional life deserved serious literary treatment helped transform modern fiction.

Concorde: The Untold Story – Part 2 of 2 8.40 pm – PBS America

The concluding instalment examines the later years of Concorde and the challenges that ultimately brought the project to an end.

Concorde remains one of the most extraordinary achievements in British and French engineering history. Even now, decades after its retirement, there is something almost futuristic about the aircraft. It represented a level of technical ambition that seems increasingly rare in modern public life.

What makes its story so compelling is the tension between achievement and practicality. Concorde was not a commercial triumph, yet it remains one of the most recognisable aircraft ever built. There is perhaps a lesson in that. Some projects matter not because they are profitable, but because they demonstrate what human ingenuity can achieve when ambition is allowed to outrun caution.

Ben Fogle: New Lives in the Wild 9.00 pm – Channel 5. Catch up via 5 streaming.

Ben Fogle meets another individual or family who have exchanged conventional life for something radically different. This week Ben meets Mark, a former international tech salesman who left his corporate career after a health scare and moved to rural western France. There, he has spent six years transforming a derelict pig farm into what he calls“Fantasy Farm”, a sustainable home and sanctuary focused on nature, creativity and simple living

The enduring popularity of this series tells us something interesting about modern society. Many viewers are not simply curious about remote locations or unusual lifestyles. They are also fascinated by people who have rejected assumptions about career, consumption and success that much of society takes for granted.

What makes the programme work is Fogle’s genuine curiosity. He rarely treats his subjects as eccentrics or visionaries. Instead he allows them to explain both the freedoms and the compromises involved in their choices. The dream of escaping modern life is often more complicated than it first appears, and the series is usually at its best when it acknowledges that reality.

Storyville: Allies in Exile 10.00 pm – BBC Four. Catch up via BBC iPlayer.

A documentary examining the difficult choices and human relationships created by political exile.

The experience of displacement is rarely confined to the practical problems of leaving one country and settling in another. Exiles carry with them memories, loyalties and political conflicts that do not necessarily disappear when they cross a border.

Part of the enduring strength of the Storyville strand is its willingness to examine international affairs through individual lives rather than simply presenting distant events as abstract political arguments.

The Playboy Bunny Murder – Parts 1 and 2 10.45 pm and 11.45 pm – ITV1

Marcel Theroux investigates a series of murders of young women during the 1970s, cases that remained unsolved for decades.

The first programme reconstructs the circumstances surrounding the killings and the original investigations. The second explores how modern forensic techniques and renewed enquiries identify a possible additional victim.

True-crime television is at its best when it restores the individuality of victims rather than treating their deaths as puzzles designed for entertainment. The social attitudes surrounding the original investigations are also worth examining, particularly the ways in which women’s occupations and lifestyles could affect how seriously they were treated.

Queer (2024) BBC Two – Transmission time to be confirmed.

Luca Guadagnino’s adaptation of William S. Burroughs’s novel stars Daniel Craig as an American expatriate living in Mexico City during the 1950s, whose obsession with a younger man becomes increasingly consuming.

Craig is a revelation, leaving the controlled masculinity of James Bond far behind. His performance is vulnerable, awkward, needy and sometimes deeply uncomfortable. It’s the portrait of a man whose desires expose emotional needs he cannot adequately express.

Guadagnino brings considerable visual invention to a story about queer longing, isolation and alienation. The film is occasionally deliberately elusive, but its willingness to explore difficult and contradictory emotions makes it worth watching.

Wednesday 4 November 2026

Odd Man Out (1947) 3.20 pm – Talking Pictures TV

There are certain films I can return to repeatedly and always discover something new. Carol Reed’s Odd Man Out is one of them. James Mason gives one of the finest performances of his career as Johnny McQueen, the leader of an underground republican organisation who is wounded during a robbery and left struggling through the streets of an unnamed Northern Irish city.

Reed transforms the city into a landscape of shadows, suspicion, fear and moral uncertainty. The cinematography is extraordinary, drawing upon the visual techniques of film noir while creating something altogether more poetic. As Johnny moves between temporary refuges, he encounters people motivated by compassion, fear, self-interest, religious conviction and political loyalty. None can entirely escape the moral consequences of the violence surrounding them.

What makes the film so powerful is that it avoids easy political answers. Johnny is neither simply a hero nor a villain. His suffering becomes a means of examining human relationships under extreme pressure. Mason’s performance is remarkably expressive, even as his character becomes increasingly exhausted and delirious. With its extraordinary atmosphere and tragic conclusion, Odd Man Out remains, for me, one of the great masterpieces of British cinema.

The Future with Hannah Fry 7.30 pm – BBC Two

Hannah Fry explores whether artificial intelligence might eventually allow us to communicate with animals. It’s the sort of proposition that once belonged entirely to the imaginary world of Doctor Dolittle, but advances in computing and animal behaviour research are opening some intriguing possibilities.

Researchers are using technology to identify patterns in animal sounds and behaviour, raising the prospect of understanding forms of communication previously inaccessible to humans.

Of course, recognising a pattern isn’t necessarily the same as understanding a language. Fry is particularly good at explaining the difference between genuine scientific progress and exaggerated technological promises.

Television’s Opening Night: How the Box Was Born 9.00 pm – BBC Four. Catch up via BBC iPlayer.

The centrepiece of BBC Four’s celebration of 90 years of British television is this fascinating 2016 documentary presented by Dallas Campbell, with Professor Danielle George and Dr Hugh Hunt.

On 2 November 1936, the BBC launched regular high-definition television broadcasting from Alexandra Palace in London. Unfortunately, no recording of that historic first transmission survives. The programme attempts to recreate the occasion using the technology available at the time.

There was a genuine technological contest underway. John Logie Baird’s mechanical system competed with the electronic system developed by Marconi-EMI. The outcome helped determine the future of television. Watching modern engineers struggle with the extraordinary machinery of the period provides a wonderful reminder of how difficult and uncertain the technological revolution actually was.

Murder in Belfast: Sisters Seeking Justice 9.00 pm – BBC Two

The concluding programme examines the continuing search for justice following the 2005 murder of Robert McCartney in Belfast.

The case attracted enormous attention because of allegations that witnesses were intimidated and evidence concealed. It exposed the continuing power of paramilitary loyalties in communities supposedly emerging from decades of conflict.

The documentary raises an uncomfortable question about the relationship between political movements and the rule of law. No organisation claiming to speak for a community should be permitted to place itself beyond accountability.

The Fools on the Hill (1986) 10.30 pm – BBC Four

Jack Rosenthal’s television drama takes a more humorous approach to the BBC’s pioneering broadcasts from Alexandra Palace.

Rosenthal had a remarkable gift for finding comedy in institutions, human weakness and the gap between grand ambitions and everyday reality. The prospect of a group of broadcasters attempting to invent television almost as they went along provides splendid material.

Placed immediately after the documentary reconstruction, this should be an enjoyable change of pace.

The Hunger Games (2012) 11.00 pm – BBC Three

The first film introduces us to Panem, a future society in which wealthy citizens of the Capitol enjoy extraordinary luxury while impoverished districts are compelled to send children to compete in a televised fight to the death.

Jennifer Lawrence is superb as Katniss Everdeen, a young woman forced into a spectacle designed to demonstrate the state’s absolute power. The premise is horrifying, but its treatment of class inequality, political propaganda and entertainment as an instrument of social control is remarkably sophisticated.

I think The Hunger Games is one of the best teenage-oriented dystopian science-fiction series yet produced. It respects its audience’s intelligence and recognises that rebellion begins when people refuse to accept injustice as the natural order of things. The sequel follows on Thursday.

Television Comes to London (1936) 11.45 pm – BBC Four

An extraordinary surviving record of the preparations for the launch of British television.

It’s effectively television’s first documentary, although it was filmed as a newsreel rather than recorded through the new broadcasting technology itself. We see equipment being installed and the preparations taking shape at Alexandra Palace.

The images possess an almost archaeological fascination. We are witnessing the birth of an industry that would eventually become central to modern culture, politics and domestic life.

JLB: The Man Who Saw the Future 12.05 am – BBC Four

A profile of television pioneer John Logie Baird, whose mechanical television experiments were central to the development of the new medium.

Baird’s story is a reminder that technological innovation rarely proceeds in a straight line. Even brilliant inventors can find their particular methods overtaken by competing developments, while their wider contributions remain historically significant.

The Birth of Television 1.20 am – BBC Four

Leslie Mitchell, the BBC’s first television announcer, looks back from 1976 on the early history of broadcasting.

Mitchell occupied a unique position, helping to introduce an entirely new form of communication to an audience that scarcely knew what to expect.

What a splendid way to conclude the evening. BBC Four has assembled these programmes largely from existing archive material, yet the result is more imaginative and informative than many expensive new commissions. Sometimes the greatest treasure a broadcaster possesses is its own history.

Thursday 5 November 2026

Whistle Down the Wind (1961) 2.35 pm – Talking Pictures TV

Bryan Forbes’s beautiful and moving film stars Hayley Mills as a Lancashire girl who discovers an escaped criminal hiding in a barn and mistakenly believes him to be Jesus Christ.

The misunderstanding provides the basis for a remarkably perceptive story about childhood innocence and adult disillusionment. The children accept the stranger’s apparent identity with a sincerity that contrasts sharply with the suspicions of the grown-ups.

Alan Bates gives a splendid performance as the bewildered fugitive. The film’s humour and tenderness never conceal its sadness, and the black-and-white photography captures the northern landscape with considerable beauty. An enduring British classic.

The Longest Day (1962) 5.25 pm – Film4

This enormous Second World War epic reconstructs the Allied landings in Normandy on 6 June 1944, drawing upon an international cast that includes John Wayne, Robert Mitchum, Richard Burton and Sean Connery.

Its great strength is the attempt to tell the story from several perspectives, including those of American, British, French and German participants. The scale of the production remains impressive, particularly in an age before computer-generated spectacle.

Inevitably, some characters are sketched rather than developed, and the film occasionally romanticises military heroism. Nevertheless, it provides a valuable sense of the confusion, courage and enormous human cost of a decisive moment in European history.

Dear Henry: Our Fight for Justice 9.00 pm – ITV1

The death of 18-year-old student Henry Nowak in Southampton in December 2025 raises deeply troubling questions about police responses to people requiring urgent help.

His family speak about their fight for answers following the emergence of body-camera footage showing officers apparently dismissing the seriousness of his condition as he lay dying.

The programme promises to be difficult viewing. But scrutiny of official conduct is essential, particularly when a young life has been lost and those responsible for protecting the public are accused of failing in their duty.

The Undertaker (2023) 9.20 pm – Talking Pictures TV

Paul McGann stars in this British crime thriller about an undertaker who becomes entangled with organised criminals after agreeing to dispose of their victims.

It’s an effectively grim premise. A profession normally associated with dignity and respect for the dead becomes a means of concealing violence and corruption.

The film draws upon familiar British gangster territory, but the unusual central character gives it an interesting twist. The moral compromises involved in performing one apparently manageable favour can have consequences far beyond anything originally anticipated.

Carrie (1976) 10.10 pm – BBC Four

Brian De Palma’s adaptation of Stephen King’s first published novel remains one of the defining horror films of the 1970s. Sissy Spacek plays Carrie White, a painfully isolated teenager subjected to bullying at school and fanatical religious control at home.

What makes the film so effective is the way supernatural horror grows out of recognisable human cruelty. Carrie’s telekinetic abilities are frightening, but so are the ordinary humiliations inflicted upon her by classmates and the psychological damage caused by her mother.

De Palma’s direction is flamboyant, sometimes almost operatic, but the emotional foundations are convincing. The notorious prom sequence remains an extraordinary achievement in tension and cinematic technique. Horror at its best often reveals the monsters already living among us.

The Hunger Games: Catching Fire (2013) 11.15 pm – BBC Three

The second film in the Hunger Games series considerably expands the political dimensions of Suzanne Collins’s dystopian world. Jennifer Lawrence returns as Katniss Everdeen, whose defiance has transformed her into an increasingly dangerous symbol of resistance.

The Capitol attempts to control public opinion through spectacle, propaganda and carefully choreographed displays of power. Meanwhile, growing unrest in the districts threatens the authoritarian order.

I regard The Hunger Games as one of the finest dystopian science-fiction film series aimed at teenage audiences. It treats young viewers as intelligent people capable of understanding difficult questions about class inequality, exploitation, media manipulation and state violence. Catching Fire develops those themes particularly well.

Mark Lawson Talks to Stephen King 11.45 pm – BBC Four

Following Carrie, Mark Lawson interviews Stephen King about his writing and extraordinary career.

King’s popularity has sometimes encouraged literary critics to underestimate him. Yet few modern writers have been as effective at exploring ordinary people’s fears and the darkness concealed beneath apparently respectable communities.

His work has inspired an enormous range of films, from Carrie and The Shining to Misery, Stand by Me and The Shawshank Redemption. The best of these reveal just how much more there is to King than supernatural horror.

Friday 6 November 2026

Dan Snow explores the remarkable continuing influence of Homer’s Odyssey, nearly three thousand years after its creation.

The survival of the Odyssey is one of civilisation’s minor miracles. Countless empires, kingdoms and political systems have disappeared since the story first emerged, yet audiences remain fascinated by Odysseus and his long journey home. Few works of literature have exercised a greater influence over Western storytelling.

What interests me most is that beneath the monsters, gods and adventures lies a very human story about exile, endurance and belonging. Almost everyone understands the desire to return home, whether literally or emotionally. The fact that Homer can still speak to modern audiences says as much about human nature as it does about literature.

Zero Dark Thirty (2012) 9.00 pm – Legend

Kathryn Bigelow’s tense political thriller follows the intelligence operation that eventually led to the killing of Osama bin Laden in Pakistan in 2011.

Jessica Chastain plays a determined CIA analyst whose obsessive pursuit of the terrorist leader dominates her personal and professional life. The film is technically accomplished, with a remarkable sense of procedural detail and mounting tension.

Yet it also raises serious moral questions, particularly through its controversial depiction of torture and intelligence gathering. A film can be brilliantly made while remaining open to criticism for the political implications of its storytelling. Zero Dark Thirty is certainly one of those films.

Have I Got News for You 9.25 pm – BBC One

Steph McGovern takes the guest presenter’s chair, with journalist Helen Lewis joining Ian Hislop and Paul Merton to dissect the week’s news.

I’ve always found Steph McGovern both very funny and a fascinating personality. Her mixture of northern directness, journalistic experience and an obvious enthusiasm for people gives her a distinctive broadcasting presence.

Have I Got News for You has survived for so long because, at its best, it combines genuine political knowledge with an ability to expose absurdity. Given the state of modern politics, there’s rarely any shortage of material.

Planes, Trains and Automobiles (1987) 10.00 pm – BBC Two

John Hughes’s comedy stars Steve Martin as a tightly wound advertising executive and John Candy as a relentlessly cheerful travelling salesman thrown together during a disastrous journey across America.

The film is frequently hilarious, largely because the two central performances complement one another so perfectly. Martin’s increasingly desperate frustration clashes with Candy’s apparently indestructible optimism.

But what elevates the film above an ordinary travel comedy is its emotional generosity. Candy’s character gradually emerges as something far more complicated than a comic nuisance, and the ending is genuinely touching. A reminder that kindness sometimes arrives in the most inconvenient form imaginable.

Leonard Cohen: Songs from a Life 10.45 pm – BBC Four. Catch up via BBC iPlayer.

Leonard Cohen was one of those rare artists whose voice seemed to acquire greater depth and authority with age.

Singer, poet, novelist and extraordinary observer of human frailty, Cohen explored love, faith, betrayal, politics and mortality with a mixture of seriousness and dry humour. His songs could be bleak, sensual, spiritual and unexpectedly funny, sometimes all at once.

This documentary offers an opportunity to appreciate a body of work that has influenced generations of musicians. Few songwriters have written so perceptively about the contradictions of human desire.

Body Double (1984) 10.50 pm – Talking Pictures TV

Brian De Palma’s provocative thriller follows a struggling actor who witnesses what appears to be a murder while spying on a woman through a telescope.

De Palma combines Hitchcockian suspense with an examination of voyeurism, sexual obsession and the artificiality of cinema itself. The result is deliberately lurid, sometimes unpleasant and frequently outrageous.

Its treatment of women and sexual violence remains controversial, but the film is also a fascinating example of De Palma’s ability to manipulate audiences through elaborate visual storytelling. It’s not subtle cinema, but it’s certainly distinctive.

Sexy Beast (2000) 12.10 am – Channel 4

Jonathan Glazer’s extraordinary British crime drama stars Ray Winstone as a retired gangster enjoying a peaceful life in Spain until the arrival of a terrifying former associate threatens everything.

Ben Kingsley’s performance as Don Logan is among the most memorable depictions of intimidation in British cinema. His character’s relentless aggression turns ordinary conversation into something resembling psychological warfare.

What makes Sexy Beast exceptional is its atmosphere. The bright Spanish sunshine offers no protection from the dark criminal world the central character thought he had escaped. Strange, brutal, blackly comic and brilliantly acted, it’s far more interesting than a conventional gangster thriller.

Streaming

Available now

Hammer: Heroes, Legends and Monsters – Prime Video

This documentary examines the remarkable history of Hammer Films, the British studio that transformed Gothic horror cinema and made international stars of actors including Christopher Lee and Peter Cushing.

Hammer’s productions were often dismissed by critics as sensationalist entertainment, but their influence was enormous. Their use of colour, sexuality, blood and Gothic atmosphere helped redefine screen horror.

Christopher Lee’s extraordinary success as Dracula was both a blessing and a burden. He became one of cinema’s most recognisable performers, yet sometimes struggled to escape the role’s shadow. An excellent companion to Saturday’s Sky Arts documentary.

A Pale View of Hills – Prime Video

Kazuo Ishiguro’s 1982 debut novel receives an appropriately elusive adaptation from writer-director Kei Ishikawa.

The story explores memory, displacement and the experiences of a Japanese woman whose recollections of postwar Nagasaki contain troubling ambiguities. Ishiguro has always been fascinated by the stories people tell themselves to make the past bearable.

This is reflective cinema, more concerned with emotional truth and unreliable memory than straightforward storytelling. Viewers willing to accept its uncertainty should find much to appreciate.

Monday 2 November

Treasure Island – Episode 4, Paramount+

Robert Louis Stevenson’s classic adventure continues, carrying viewers deeper into its world of treasure, greed and shifting loyalties.

What has allowed Treasure Island to survive for nearly a century and a half is not the treasure hunt itself but the character of Long John Silver. Stevenson created a figure who remains endlessly fascinating because he refuses to fit comfortably into the categories of hero or villain.

At its best, the series understands that ambiguity. The adventure is enjoyable enough, but the real attraction lies in watching characters navigate questions of loyalty, friendship and self-interest in a world where trust is constantly being tested.

Tuesday 3 November

Mike Tyson: Return of the Mike – Netflix

Following closely on the heels of the generally impressive four-part documentary Tyson, this special features the former heavyweight champion appearing before a live theatre audience to recount anecdotes from his extraordinary life.

It’s not quite stand-up comedy, though Tyson’s turbulent career certainly contains moments that would seem implausible if invented by a dramatist. His charisma and unpredictable personality make him a compelling storyteller.

Nevertheless, I remain troubled by the earlier documentary’s treatment of his rape conviction, which many viewers considered disturbingly benign. Tyson’s achievements as a boxer are undeniable, but celebrity should not become an excuse for minimising serious wrongdoing. Whether this stage appearance confronts those contradictions or simply adds to the mythology will be worth considering.

Wednesday 4 November

The Greatest – All eight episodes, Prime Video

Muhammad Ali was much more than an extraordinary boxer. He was a humanitarian, political activist, Black nationalist and global cultural icon whose refusal to conform to the expectations imposed upon him made him one of the most influential figures of the twentieth century.

This authorised drama explores his life both inside and outside the ring. Jaalen Best plays Ali, and the series promises to consider his relationships, personal struggles and political convictions alongside his sporting achievements.

Ali’s refusal to fight in Vietnam, his association with the Nation of Islam and his willingness to sacrifice his career for his principles make him a compelling dramatic subject. A worthwhile biography must recognise those contradictions rather than simply celebrating the champion.

Thursday 5 November

Black Doves – Series 2, Netflix

Keira Knightley and Ben Whishaw return in this stylish British espionage thriller about a secret organisation operating in the shadows of political power.

The first series successfully blended violent intrigue with black humour and an unexpectedly affecting relationship between its two central characters. Knightley was particularly effective as a woman whose apparently respectable family life concealed dangerous loyalties.

The second series raises the stakes as political ambitions and personal secrets become increasingly entangled. With its sharp dialogue and unconventional mixture of spy drama and comedy, this is a welcome return.

Friday 6 November

Dexter: Resurrection – Series 2, Episode 2, Paramount+

Michael C. Hall returns as Dexter Morgan, television’s most disquieting vigilante killer.

The durability of the Dexter franchise remains slightly surprising. On paper, a series built around a sympathetic serial killer should have exhausted itself long ago. Yet the character continues to fascinate because he embodies a question audiences never quite resolve: can we forgive monstrous actions when committed against even worse people?

That moral uncertainty remains the programme’s greatest strength. Like all long-running franchises, Dexter sometimes risks repeating itself, but Hall’s performance continues to anchor the series. Few television actors have inhabited a character so completely for so long.

Leaving soon

The Wicker Man (1973) – BBC iPlayer, available until Sunday 1 November

Robin Hardy’s extraordinary folk horror follows a devout Christian police officer investigating a disappearance on a remote Scottish island.

Christopher Lee gives one of his finest performances as Lord Summerisle, the charismatic leader of a community whose apparently idyllic customs conceal something deeply sinister.

It’s a masterpiece of atmosphere, religious conflict and creeping dread. Far more than a conventional horror film, it examines the clash between competing systems of belief and the dangers of absolute certainty. Essential viewing before it disappears.

The Man Who Would Be King (1975) – BBC iPlayer, available until Tuesday 3 November

John Huston’s magnificent adaptation of Rudyard Kipling’s adventure stars Sean Connery and Michael Caine as two former British soldiers who set out to make their fortunes in a remote region of Afghanistan.

What begins as an exuberant adventure gradually develops into a darker exploration of imperial ambition, greed and the corrupting influence of power.

Connery and Caine are wonderful together, combining humour, charm and an increasing sense of tragic inevitability. It’s one of the great adventure films, but also a cautionary tale about the arrogance of men who believe they can rule other people’s lives.

Radio

Saturday 31 October 2026

Unlikely: A Love Across the Political Divide

12.05 pm – BBC World Service

Love can flourish in the most unlikely political circumstances. This remarkable story concerns Colombian couple Jorge and Catalina Suárez, whose backgrounds could hardly be more different.

Jorge is a former member of the FARC guerrilla organisation and the son of Mono Jojoy, one of its most notorious commanders, killed during a Colombian military operation in 2010. Catalina is a centre-right journalist with close connections to former president Álvaro Uribe and a longstanding opponent of FARC.

Their relationship offers a fascinating insight into Colombia’s painful history of political violence and the possibility of reconciliation between individuals divided by seemingly irreconcilable loyalties. Sometimes personal relationships achieve what political negotiation struggles to accomplish.

Peter O’Toole Is Unwell

3.00 pm – BBC Radio 4

Playwright Terry Johnson explores the life and personality of the legendary Peter O’Toole, an actor whose extraordinary talent was accompanied by a reputation for spectacular excess.

The title is a knowing reference to Jeffrey Bernard Is Unwell, Keith Waterhouse’s celebrated stage play about the hard-drinking Spectator columnist, in which O’Toole gave one of his most acclaimed performances.

O’Toole was capable of extraordinary brilliance, from Lawrence of Arabia onwards, but his career also contained serious artistic misjudgements and personal difficulties. Johnson’s drama promises a portrait that captures the contradictions of a remarkable theatrical personality.

Soundtracking: Horror with Ayanna Witter-Johnson

8.00 pm – Magic Classical

Composer and musician Ayanna Witter-Johnson explores the music that has helped make horror cinema so terrifying.

Consider how much of the fear generated by Psycho, Halloween or The Exorcist depends upon sound. Remove the music and many of cinema’s most frightening sequences lose much of their power.

This Halloween special examines the techniques used by composers to generate suspense, anticipation and shock. An excellent accompaniment to the week’s horror films, and a reminder that sometimes what we hear is more frightening than what we see.

Tuesday 3 November 2026

Start Making Sense: Visionary Sight

4.00 pm – BBC Radio 4

Professor Tom Shakespeare, the sociologist and disability researcher, begins a three-part exploration of the senses through the creative experiences of disabled artists.

The series considers how physical differences can influence artistic expression and challenge conventional assumptions about perception.

It’s a welcome opportunity to move beyond the familiar portrayal of disability solely in terms of disadvantage. Different sensory experiences can offer distinctive ways of understanding and interpreting the world, enriching artistic culture rather than diminishing it.

Thursday 5 November 2026

Threads of Healing

2.15 pm – BBC Radio 4

Pavinder Shergill’s drama tells the story of an emotional reunion between a mother and daughter.

Family relationships can carry extraordinary emotional weight, particularly when separation has created years of unresolved memories and unanswered questions. Reconciliation is seldom as straightforward as either party might hope.

This promises to be an intimate and affecting exploration of family, identity and the possibility of repairing relationships damaged by circumstances and time.

And that’s Culture Vulture for 31 October to 6 November 2026.

It’s been a particularly rich week, from the extraordinary beginnings of British television at Alexandra Palace to the enduring achievements of Christopher Lee and Ingmar Bergman. There are powerful reminders of the struggle for justice, some excellent science fiction, and plenty of opportunities to enjoy the darker side of cinema as Halloween arrives.

Do make time for Odd Man Out if you’ve never seen it. Some films deserve their reputation, and Carol Reed’s masterpiece is certainly one of them.

By Patrick Harrington | Counter Culture

Picture credits

Odd Man Out: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0039677/, Fair use, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?curid=19887521

Concorde: Eduard Marmet, CC BY-SA 3.0 GFDL 1.2, via Wikimedia Commons

Advert

Leave a Comment

Culture Vulture: The Best TV, Films, Streaming and Radio for 24–30 October 2026

Leave a Comment

The Mentalist: Red Handed Review – Patrick Jane Hits the Jackpot

Spoilers! One of the pleasures of The Mentalist’s first season is watching the writers discover situations that suit Patrick Jane almost too well. In “Red Handed” they send him into a Nevada casino and the fit is so perfect that the episode practically writes itself. Long before the mystery begins to take shape, you get the sense that Jane has found an environment built on exactly the same principles he uses every day: observation, manipulation and the ability to convince people they’re making their own choices.

The case starts with an image designed to grab attention. A severed hand found near the California-Nevada border leads the CBI to Edwin McClain, co-owner of a luxury casino whose death quickly proves to be anything but straightforward. It’s a suitably grisly opening, although the episode’s real attraction lies not in the murder itself but in the world surrounding it.

Casinos have appeared in countless crime dramas over the years, usually as glamorous backdrops populated by gangsters, card sharks and suspicious businessmen. What The Mentalist understands is that the setting works because it mirrors the way Jane thinks. Every flashing light, every carefully controlled environment and every manufactured sense of possibility exists to influence behaviour. Jane walks into that world and immediately starts pulling it apart.

Simon Baker is clearly having fun here. There are episodes where Jane appears mildly detached from the people around him, solving cases because that’s simply what he does. “Red Handed” is different. Whether he’s irritating casino management, casually counting cards or drifting through the gaming floor with a knowing smile, he looks genuinely energised.

The confidence is infectious.

A lesser show might have turned the casino into a distraction from the investigation. Instead it becomes part of the investigation. Jane understands that gamblers, executives and suspects all operate under similar pressures. They tell themselves stories. They convince themselves they’re in control. The trick is making those stories collapse.

The mystery itself is less interested in shocking twists than in exposing layers of deception. McClain’s death sends the team through a maze of financial interests, personal grudges and uneasy partnerships. Everyone seems to be protecting something. Money hangs over nearly every conversation, shaping loyalties and creating tensions that have clearly existed long before the murder.

What keeps the episode moving is the way information emerges. Rather than relying on convenient forensic breakthroughs, the script leans into Jane’s greatest strength. He doesn’t solve crimes because he notices tiny fibres under a microscope. He solves them because he understands how people behave when they are frightened.

That distinction has always separated The Mentalist from many of its contemporaries.

At the height of television’s forensic-procedural boom, the series took a different route. Jane’s toolkit is human rather than scientific. He watches faces. He listens to tone. He notices hesitation. Most importantly, he knows exactly how to make people uncomfortable. Several scenes in “Red Handed” revolve around little more than conversations, yet they’re often more suspenseful than the action sequences found in far more expensive productions.

Robin Tunney also gets some enjoyable material as Lisbon attempts the impossible task of keeping Jane focused. Their partnership is one of the strongest elements of the series and episodes like this remind you why. Lisbon spends much of the hour looking as though she’s supervising an exceptionally intelligent teenager who refuses to behave himself in public. The frustration is real, but so is the trust.

She never quite knows what he’s doing, yet she usually knows he’s onto something.

The supporting team continue to provide reliable balance. Tim Kang’s Cho remains magnificently resistant to the casino’s charms. Whether he’s interviewing witnesses or walking through a room packed with slot machines, his expression rarely changes. The deadpan delivery continues to be one of the show’s secret weapons.

Rigsby, by contrast, reacts exactly as most people probably would when dropped into a luxury casino. There’s an underlying sense of enthusiasm that helps ground the character and keeps him distinct from Cho’s unshakeable calm. The contrast between the pair remains simple but effective.

Where the episode really succeeds is in recognising that casinos are built on self-deception. Every visitor believes they can beat the system. Every losing streak feels temporary. Every bad decision comes wrapped in optimism. The crime at the centre of the episode ultimately grows from the same mentality. People take risks because they believe consequences happen to somebody else.

Until they don’t.

Jane understands this long before anyone else does. For him the solution isn’t hidden in a ledger or buried inside a forensic report. It’s sitting in plain sight, concealed only by the stories people keep telling themselves. Watching him strip away those stories is where the episode finds its greatest satisfaction.

The climactic reveal follows a familiar pattern for the series, yet it works precisely because of that familiarity. Jane doesn’t overpower anyone. He doesn’t uncover a miraculous last-minute clue. He simply creates the right circumstances and waits for the truth to expose itself. The elegance of the method is part of the appeal.

Looking back, “Red Handed” feels like one of the first episodes that fully understands the strengths of its central character. The murder mystery is solid, the performances are strong and the casino setting provides plenty of visual flair, but what lingers afterwards is the sense of watching Patrick Jane operate on home turf.

In a world built on bluffing, reading people and pushing luck further than common sense should allow, he finally looks completely at ease. That’s what makes the episode memorable. The case may belong to the CBI, but the casino belongs to Jane from the moment he walks through the door.

And, as it turns out, he’s the best player in the building.

By Chris Storton

Leave a Comment

The Mentalist, Season 1, Episode 5: “Redwood” Review – When Memory Becomes the Enemy

Warning Spoilers! This episode is particularly unsettling – a murder mystery in which the principal suspect cannot remember whether she committed the crime. Most detective dramas concern themselves with people who know the truth but are determined to conceal it. In “Redwood”, the fifth episode of the first season of The Mentalist, we are presented with something rather different. A young woman may hold the key to a murder investigation, but the truth appears to have disappeared from her own mind.

It is an intriguing premise, and one that allows the series to explore some interesting questions about memory, trauma, prejudice and the reliability of appearances. It also gives us another opportunity to understand Patrick Jane, a man whose remarkable ability to read other people is matched by his considerable difficulty in coming to terms with his own past.

Following the financial intrigue and calculated greed of the previous episode, “Ladies in Red”, we move into an altogether different setting. The wealthy homes and expensive possessions are replaced by the forests and isolated roads surrounding the small Californian community of Redwood Point. There is something almost Gothic about the location. The towering trees, remote buildings and enclosed spaces create an atmosphere in which danger seems to lurk just beyond the limits of visibility.

Two young women, Nicole Gilbert and Kara Palmer, have disappeared after leaving a party. Their abandoned car is discovered in woodland, and the California Bureau of Investigation is called in. Jane soon discovers Kara’s body beneath the vehicle. She has been stabbed to death. Nicole, meanwhile, is missing.

When Nicole eventually reappears, the circumstances could hardly be more incriminating. She is covered in blood, carrying a knife and behaving in a confused and distressed manner. Worse still, she cannot remember what happened.

For the local sheriff, the conclusion seems obvious. Nicole killed her friend and is either concealing the truth or conveniently unable to recall it.

Jane is far less certain.

This is where the episode becomes interesting, because it exposes the difference between conventional police thinking and Jane’s approach to investigation. The authorities see physical evidence pointing towards an obvious suspect. Jane looks at the suspect herself. Her behaviour, her fear, her reactions and, perhaps most importantly, the things she cannot explain.

He believes Nicole is innocent, not because he has discovered some overlooked forensic evidence, but because her distress appears genuine. Nicole’s conversations with Jane are among the episode’s most effective scenes because they reveal how uncertain she is about her own mind. She does not merely fear being accused of murder; she fears that the accusations might be true. Jane quickly recognises that distinction. Rather than treating her fragmented recollections as evidence, he treats them as signs of a trauma she cannot yet fully process. The tension comes from the possibility that both Nicole and the investigators may be drawing conclusions from memories neither fully understands.

Of course, this presents a problem. Genuine distress is not proof of innocence. Guilty people can be frightened, confused and remorseful. Jane’s confidence in his own judgement occasionally borders on arrogance, and the series is generally more entertaining when it allows us to recognise that uncomfortable truth.

Simon Baker is particularly effective in these quieter scenes. His Patrick Jane is often at his most amusing when exposing the pomposity of authority figures or effortlessly puncturing somebody’s elaborate deception. Here, however, we see another side of him.

He can be surprisingly gentle.

Jane recognises that Nicole is vulnerable and that simply treating her as a criminal will achieve very little. His attempts to recover her memories require a degree of sensitivity that we do not always associate with his character. Yet even here, his compassion is inseparable from his willingness to manipulate circumstances.

He is not above pushing people towards uncomfortable discoveries if he believes the result justifies it.

That raises one of the episode’s more interesting moral questions. How far should an investigator go in persuading a traumatised person to revisit an experience they may be psychologically unprepared to confront?

Jane believes that unlocking Nicole’s memory is essential to establishing the truth. Teresa Lisbon is understandably more cautious.

The relationship between Jane and Lisbon continues to develop nicely. Robin Tunney gives Lisbon an authority that feels entirely natural. She is neither an obstructive bureaucrat nor a conveniently gullible superior who exists merely to admire Jane’s brilliance. She recognises his extraordinary abilities, but she also knows that his methods can create serious difficulties.

Their exchanges provide some of the series’ most enjoyable moments because the tension between them is rooted in genuinely different approaches to justice.

Lisbon believes in procedures, evidence and responsibility. Jane believes in observation, intuition and the capacity to expose human weakness. Neither approach is sufficient on its own. Several moments in the investigation illustrate this contrast particularly well. Lisbon remains focused on evidence that could withstand scrutiny in court, while Jane is prepared to follow instincts that cannot easily be justified on paper. The episode never entirely endorses either position. Instead, it suggests that solving the case depends upon a balance between Lisbon’s caution and Jane’s willingness to question assumptions that everyone else has accepted.

In “Redwood”, their differences are particularly important because a young woman’s future depends upon getting things right.

There is also a question of social prejudice running through the investigation.

Nicole’s troubled family background and previous difficulties with the law make her an easy target for suspicion. The suspicion directed towards Nicole often seems to solidify before the evidence has been properly examined. Once she reappears covered in blood and unable to remember what happened, many characters treat the case as effectively solved. The episode’s criticism of that attitude is one of its strongest aspects, because the audience can see how quickly a person’s reputation can become more influential than the facts.

Kara, by contrast, comes from a more respectable and apparently stable home. There is an unspoken assumption that one young woman is more likely to have committed a violent crime than the other simply because of the circumstances of her upbringing.

It is hardly an unfamiliar phenomenon.

People are frequently judged not only by what they have done but by where they come from, the people they associate with and the reputation they have acquired. Once an individual has been labelled troublesome, subsequent events tend to be interpreted through that reputation.

The episode suggests that the investigation is in danger of becoming an exercise in confirming existing suspicions rather than examining all the possibilities.

Jane, for all his faults, is particularly good at recognising when people are seeing what they expect to see.

The apparent simplicity of Nicole and Kara’s friendship also begins to unravel. As the investigation progresses, we discover that the relationship was not quite as straightforward as it first appeared. Personal loyalties, romantic entanglements and betrayals complicate the picture.

This is familiar territory for crime drama, but it serves a useful purpose here. Young people can experience friendship and romantic disappointment with an intensity that adults sometimes dismiss. A betrayal that might seem relatively insignificant to an outsider can feel devastating to those involved.

Yet “Redwood” does not ultimately reduce its central crime to a straightforward tale of youthful jealousy. The personal tensions become part of a more disturbing story, one in which Nicole’s missing memories conceal a terrible experience.

The episode’s treatment of memory is perhaps its most fascinating feature, although it should be approached with a little scepticism.

Television dramas have long been attracted to the idea that the mind can protect itself from unbearable experiences by blocking access to traumatic memories. Such stories offer obvious dramatic possibilities. A forgotten event becomes a mystery within a mystery, waiting for the right sound, image or emotional stimulus to unlock it.

Here, Jane uses familiar surroundings and sensory associations to encourage Nicole to reconstruct the events of the night Kara was killed. These sequences are effective because they place the viewer in much the same position as Nicole herself. Each fragment of recollection appears to offer clarity only to raise further questions. Rather than relying solely on exposition, the episode allows the audience to experience some of the confusion and uncertainty created by memories that refuse to form a coherent narrative.

It makes for compelling television, but real memory is considerably less reliable than detective fiction sometimes suggests. Trauma can certainly disrupt memory, but recollection is not a perfect recording that can simply be replayed. Memory can be fragmented, altered and influenced by suggestion. Recovering an apparently forgotten experience does not necessarily guarantee its accuracy.

This is worth remembering because the methods employed by Jane, however successful within the fictional world of The Mentalist, would raise serious questions if used in a real criminal investigation.

There is a danger in confusing psychological insight with scientific certainty.

Nevertheless, the scenes in which Nicole struggles to remember are among the episode’s strongest. Shelby Fenner gives a convincing performance as a young woman caught between terror and uncertainty. Her character is not simply frightened of what somebody else may have done. She is frightened of what she herself might be capable of doing.

That is a particularly cruel position in which to find oneself.

The direction makes effective use of the woodland setting. The forests are beautiful, but they are also threatening. Their apparent tranquillity disguises the possibility of violence, and the isolation creates the uncomfortable feeling that help may be a very long way away.

John Behring keeps the story moving without allowing the atmospheric elements to overwhelm the investigation. The result is an episode that feels rather more ominous than some of its predecessors.

As the truth emerges, the narrative becomes more conventional, with the investigation leading towards a dangerous confrontation. Lisbon finds herself in considerable peril, providing a reminder that Jane’s cleverness does not remove the physical risks faced by the people around him.

Indeed, there is an interesting reversal here. Jane is usually the person who walks confidently into dangerous situations, apparently unconcerned by the consequences. In this case, Lisbon must confront the immediate threat while Jane contributes from a distance.

The sequence works because it gives Lisbon the opportunity to demonstrate that she is considerably more than Jane’s supervisor or occasional foil.

There is also something rather satisfying about seeing his psychological tricks applied in a situation where the stakes are genuinely high.

One criticism is that the eventual solution follows a familiar pattern. The episode is at its most original when examining Nicole’s uncertainty and the assumptions made about her guilt. Once the identity of the killer becomes clearer, some of that psychological complexity gives way to more conventional thriller mechanics.

The villain’s motivation is also less compelling than the circumstances surrounding the crime. We have become invested in Nicole’s psychological ordeal, and the explanation of the murder cannot quite match the disturbing possibilities raised by the opening.

But perhaps that is not the point.

What matters most is that the apparent murderer turns out to have been a victim, and that somebody whose background encouraged others to distrust her proves to have been judged unfairly.

There is a distinctly humane argument running beneath the entertainment. People are not necessarily what they appear to be, and those who are easiest to accuse are not always those who deserve suspicion.

It would be tempting to describe this episode as demonstrating Jane’s empathy, but that is only part of the story.

Jane is an interesting character precisely because his empathy is selective and complicated. He can show extraordinary understanding towards a frightened young woman while casually humiliating somebody he considers dishonest or foolish. He can recognise another person’s suffering yet remain remarkably insensitive to the discomfort caused by his own behaviour.

There is a contradiction at the heart of his personality.

His understanding of human emotions is both a gift and a weapon.

We also know that behind his apparently effortless confidence lies the terrible loss of his wife and daughter at the hands of Red John. Jane’s professional life is devoted to exposing other people’s secrets, but his own tragedy remains unresolved.

Perhaps this is why he responds so strongly to people who have suffered experiences beyond their control.

Helping Nicole recover some understanding of what happened cannot undo her ordeal, any more than Jane’s pursuit of criminals can restore his family. But it does offer a small opportunity to bring order to a world that has suddenly become terrifying and incomprehensible.

There is genuine poignancy in that.

“Redwood” is not a flawless episode. Its understanding of traumatic memory is more convenient for storytelling than entirely convincing as psychology, and the final resolution lacks some of the sophistication of its central premise.

Even so, it is among the more affecting early instalments of The Mentalist.

It demonstrates that the series is capable of more than ingenious revelations, amusing exchanges and the exposure of elaborate lies. It can also examine the consequences of violence for those left behind.

Most importantly, it gives Simon Baker the opportunity to broaden his portrayal of Patrick Jane. Beneath the showmanship, the mischievous smile and the sometimes insufferable certainty is a man who understands suffering rather better than he lets on.

We are beginning to see why Jane is such an appealing character. He is not necessarily a good man in the conventional sense. He is manipulative, frequently arrogant and perfectly willing to ignore rules he considers inconvenient.

Yet he has an instinctive sympathy for people who have been hurt, particularly when those in authority are too eager to condemn them.

That contradiction is central to the success of the series.

In “Redwood”, the most important mystery is not simply who killed Kara Palmer. It is whether Nicole Gilbert can trust her own mind, and whether those investigating the crime can look beyond the evidence that seems to condemn her.

The episode leaves us with a thought worth considering beyond the boundaries of detective fiction.

The truth is not always concealed by somebody telling lies. Sometimes it is obscured by fear, prejudice and the dangerous certainty of people who believe they already know the answer.

And Patrick Jane, of all people, understands the dangers of certainty.

An engaging, atmospheric and unexpectedly compassionate episode that deepens our understanding of Jane while asking some uncomfortable questions about guilt, memory and the ease with which suspicion becomes judgement.

By Chris Storton

Leave a Comment

Culture Vulture: Best TV, Films and Streaming for 17–23 October 2026

St Fagans National Museum of History , Cardiff ,Wales, UK 27 Oct 2024 : Visitor Message board to the Aberfan Disaster 1966

Sixty years ago, on the morning of 21 October 1966, disaster struck the Welsh mining village of Aberfan. A huge mass of coal waste, saturated by heavy rain, collapsed and surged down the mountainside, engulfing houses and Pantglas Junior School. By the time the rescue operations were over, 144 people had died, including 116 children.

It remains one of the most heartbreaking tragedies in modern British history. The children had barely begun their final day of school before the half-term holiday. Many never came home.

Yet what makes Aberfan particularly disturbing is that this was not simply an unavoidable natural disaster. The spoil tips above the village had been allowed to grow despite longstanding concerns about their stability. Watercourses beneath the waste made the location especially dangerous. The National Coal Board had failed in its responsibilities, and the subsequent tribunal exposed a catalogue of negligence.

The grief was compounded by what followed. Families who had suffered unimaginable losses found themselves confronting an establishment reluctant to accept responsibility and, at times, more concerned with protecting institutions than helping those they had failed. Even the question of removing the remaining dangerous tips became another battle.

This week’s television commemorations are particularly important. Aberfan: The Village That Fought Back (BBC Two, Monday, 9pm) examines the community’s fight for justice and the resistance it encountered. Meanwhile, Alex Jones: Un Diwrnod yn Aberfan (BBC iPlayer, from Sunday) offers another opportunity to remember the lives lost and the people left behind.

For me, Aberfan is also a story about class and power. It raises questions about whose warnings are heard, whose lives are valued and what happens when institutions become more concerned with defending themselves than acknowledging their mistakes. Those questions have certainly not disappeared in the intervening sixty years.

This is our principal recommendation of the week. These programmes deserve to be watched, discussed and remembered.

There are two other highlights I would particularly recommend.

The first is The Day the Earth Stood Still (Talking Pictures, Saturday, 4pm). This 1951 science-fiction classic is one of my favourite films. Its message about the dangers of militarism and humanity’s capacity for self-destruction is just as relevant now as it was during the early Cold War. There was a remake in 2008, which I actually rather like, but the original remains comfortably superior. Sometimes the simplest approach is also the most powerful.

Our third highlight is Thursday’s Mercury Prize: Album of the Year (BBC Four, 9.30pm). In an age dominated by streaming playlists and individual tracks, it might seem strange to celebrate the album as a distinct artistic achievement. Yet the album remains alive and well. It allows musicians to develop ideas, establish moods and tell stories in ways that individual songs often cannot. This year’s ceremony, featuring performances by some of the most interesting names in British music, promises to be more of a miniature festival than a conventional awards show.

Elsewhere, Stacey Dooley appears to be taking over the television schedules. Every time I look through the listings, there she is again. Fortunately, she’s very good at what she does, and her documentaries continue to investigate worthwhile and sometimes uncomfortable subjects.

We’re also particularly pleased to see another Storyville documentary. Regular readers will know how much we value this strand, which consistently introduces British audiences to films that might otherwise struggle to find a place on mainstream television.

Among the films, there’s everything from Hitchcock and Agnès Varda to Edgar Wright, a little political satire, some classic horror and several powerful examinations of injustice.

Plenty to enjoy, and plenty to think about.

Saturday 17 October

North by Northwest (1959) — BBC Two, 2.15pm

Alfred Hitchcock’s magnificent espionage thriller stars Cary Grant as Roger Thornhill, an advertising executive mistaken for a secret agent and pursued across America by people who want him dead.

The film combines mistaken identity, romantic intrigue and spectacular set pieces, including the famous crop-duster sequence and the climactic confrontation on Mount Rushmore.

Grant is perfectly cast as the sophisticated innocent whose comfortable existence is turned upside down. Eva Marie Saint provides an intriguing romantic foil, while James Mason is wonderfully sinister.

Hitchcock was a master of suspense, but what makes this film so enjoyable is its elegance and humour. More than sixty years later, it remains a model of popular filmmaking.

The Day the Earth Stood Still (1951) — Talking Pictures TV, 4pm

One of my favourite science-fiction films, and one whose message about peace seems especially appropriate for our troubled times.

Directed by Robert Wise, the story begins when a flying saucer lands in Washington and an extraterrestrial visitor, Klaatu, emerges accompanied by an imposing robot called Gort.

Klaatu has come with a warning. Humanity’s development of increasingly destructive weapons threatens not just Earth but potentially the wider universe. Unless human beings learn to control their aggression, consequences will follow.

Michael Rennie’s restrained performance gives Klaatu a quiet dignity. The film avoids the usual temptation to make aliens into monsters and instead invites us to look critically at ourselves.

Released during the Cold War, it reflects contemporary anxieties about nuclear annihilation, but its underlying concerns have lost none of their force.

The 2008 remake starring Keanu Reeves is quite good and shifts the emphasis towards environmental destruction. Nevertheless, the original is much better. It trusts its ideas, its dialogue and its audience. There are lessons here that humanity has still not fully learned.

Talking Pictures: World Cinema Classics — BBC Four, 9pm

Celia Imrie guides viewers through some of the great achievements of international cinema, considering filmmakers including Akira Kurosawa, Agnès Varda, François Truffaut, Luis Buñuel and Ingmar Bergman.

It’s an impressive collection of directors whose approaches differ considerably but who share a determination to explore what cinema can achieve.

Kurosawa brought extraordinary visual power and moral complexity to Japanese cinema. Varda helped pioneer the French New Wave with her distinctive, humane approach. Truffaut examined childhood, love and the cinema itself. Buñuel used surrealism to attack conventional morality, while Bergman explored faith, death, relationships and the human condition.

An excellent introduction for newcomers and a welcome opportunity for established film enthusiasts to revisit familiar favourites.

American Star (2024) — Film4, 9pm

Ian McShane stars as Wilson, an ageing assassin who travels to Fuerteventura to carry out what should be a straightforward assignment.

Instead, he finds himself drawn into the rhythms of island life and begins forming relationships with people who know nothing of his violent profession.

The film takes an unusually reflective approach to the hitman thriller. Rather than relying upon constant action, it examines loneliness, mortality and the possibility of finding something meaningful in an otherwise bleak existence.

McShane’s commanding screen presence makes him ideally suited to the role. A thoughtful variation on familiar territory.

The Everly Brothers: Harmonies from Heaven — Sky Arts, 9pm; NOW catch-up

Don and Phil Everly possessed one of the most beautiful vocal blends in popular music.

Their harmonies influenced everyone from the Beatles to Simon & Garfunkel, while songs such as Bye Bye Love, Wake Up Little Susie and All I Have to Do Is Dream helped establish the sound of modern popular music.

This documentary explores their musical achievements, family background and frequently troubled relationship.

There’s something poignant about the contrast between those immaculate harmonies and the personal tensions that eventually drove the brothers apart.

A reminder that music can create an impression of perfect unity even when the musicians themselves are struggling to maintain it.

Cléo from 5 to 7 (1962) — BBC Four, 9.45pm

Agnès Varda’s celebrated French New Wave drama follows a young singer wandering through Paris while awaiting the results of a medical examination.

Corinne Marchand plays Cléo, whose apparent confidence gradually gives way to fear and self-examination.

Varda uses the streets, cafés and everyday encounters of Paris to explore mortality, femininity and the experience of being watched and judged.

The film’s treatment of time is particularly interesting. What begins as an ordinary afternoon becomes an intense examination of what it means to be alive.

Beautifully observed, humane and surprisingly accessible, this remains one of the outstanding achievements of French cinema.

Death Race 2000 (1975) — Great Action, 11.25pm

Paul Bartel’s outrageous dystopian action film takes place in a future America where a murderous cross-country motor race has become a major spectator sport.

Drivers score points by killing pedestrians, and the public treats the carnage as entertainment.

David Carradine stars as the mysterious Frankenstein, with Sylvester Stallone among his competitors.

The film is often remembered for its ludicrous violence, bizarre characters and low-budget exploitation thrills. What sometimes gets overlooked is the political satire.

Beneath the deliberately excessive action lies a savage attack on authoritarianism, sensationalist media, celebrity culture and the manipulation of public opinion.

Its vision of a society entertained by cruelty is uncomfortably recognisable. Sometimes satire has to be outrageous to make its point.

Saint Maud (2019) — Film4, 1.15am, early Sunday

Rose Glass’s unsettling psychological horror stars Morfydd Clark as Maud, a young private carer whose intense religious convictions become increasingly dangerous.

Caring for Amanda, a terminally ill former dancer played by Jennifer Ehle, Maud convinces herself that she has a divine mission to save her patient’s soul.

What makes the film so effective is its refusal to offer straightforward explanations. Is Maud experiencing religious revelation, psychological disturbance or some frightening combination of the two?

Clark’s performance is extraordinary, capturing both vulnerability and fanaticism.

This is an intelligent examination of religious obsession, loneliness and the frightening consequences of absolute certainty.

Sunday 18 October

The Addams Family (1991) — ITV2, 4pm

The gloriously macabre Addams family return in Barry Sonnenfeld’s film adaptation of Charles Addams’s famous creations.

Anjelica Huston and Raul Julia are wonderfully cast as Morticia and Gomez, while Christina Ricci almost steals the picture as the magnificently deadpan Wednesday.

The joke, of course, is that this supposedly monstrous family is often more affectionate and loyal than the respectable people surrounding them.

The film revels in gothic imagery, eccentric humour and cheerful disregard for conventional values.

A thoroughly enjoyable comedy that has lost little of its appeal.

The Balkans: Europe’s Forgotten Frontier — BBC Two, 8pm

BBC Europe editor Katya Adler travels through Croatia, Bosnia and Albania, exploring how the region has changed since the violent break-up of Yugoslavia and the wider upheavals of the 1990s.

The wars that followed Yugoslavia’s disintegration left deep political, social and psychological scars. Old tensions have not simply disappeared, while questions of national identity and European integration remain contentious.

Adler is a knowledgeable guide to a region often neglected in British coverage of European affairs.

The Balkans have repeatedly played an important part in European history. Understanding their present requires an appreciation of the complicated past that continues to shape everyday life.

Kevin McCloud’s Classic Car Road Trips — Channel 4, 8pm (1/6)

Kevin McCloud combines an enthusiasm for design with a journey through the history and culture of some of Europe’s most celebrated cars.

His opening trip takes him along the French Riviera, travelling from Cannes towards Monaco in a beautiful 1960s Citroën DS convertible.

The DS was one of the most remarkable cars ever produced. When introduced in 1955, its futuristic appearance and advanced engineering seemed to belong to another age.

Its hydropneumatic suspension and elegant styling helped establish it as an icon of French design.

There are worse ways to spend an hour than travelling through the Riviera in such a magnificent machine, particularly with McCloud explaining the design philosophy behind it.

Living (2022) — Film4, 9pm

Bill Nighy gives one of his finest performances in this deeply moving drama about an emotionally reserved civil servant who discovers that he has a terminal illness.

Set in 1950s London, the film follows a man who has spent much of his life observing routine and convention but now begins questioning what that life has amounted to.

Adapted by Kazuo Ishiguro from Akira Kurosawa’s Ikiru, the film explores mortality, bureaucracy and the possibility of meaningful action.

Nighy brings an extraordinary restraint to the central performance.

It’s a gentle, thoughtful and ultimately uplifting film about the importance of making our limited time count.

Time — BBC One, 9pm (series finale; full series on iPlayer)

We’ve deliberately avoided saying too much about this latest series because we’ve been saving it up for a proper binge-watch.

David Tennant stars as prison officer Bobby Bailey, and Tennant’s involvement is reason enough to attract our attention. He’s one of those actors who can make even a quiet moment compelling.

The prison setting also promises an opportunity to explore questions of institutional power, punishment, responsibility and human vulnerability.

Rather than concentrate on the finale alone, our recommendation is to watch the series from the beginning on BBC iPlayer.

Some dramas are best experienced as a complete work, allowing their characters and tensions to develop without interruption. This looks like one of them.

French Connection II (1975) — Talking Pictures TV, 10.10pm

Gene Hackman returns as the obsessive New York detective Jimmy ‘Popeye’ Doyle in John Frankenheimer’s sequel to William Friedkin’s celebrated crime thriller.

This time Doyle travels to Marseille in pursuit of the heroin trafficker Alain Charnier, played once again by Fernando Rey.

The change of location gives the sequel a distinctive character, while Hackman delivers another uncompromising performance.

It’s a darker, sometimes more psychologically disturbing film than its predecessor, particularly in its treatment of Doyle’s vulnerability.

A worthy sequel to one of the defining American crime films of the 1970s.

Priscilla (2023) — BBC Two, 10.45pm

Sofia Coppola approaches the Elvis Presley story from an unusual perspective, concentrating on the experiences of Priscilla Beaulieu, who met the singer when she was still a teenager.

Cailee Spaeny plays Priscilla, while Jacob Elordi portrays Elvis.

Rather than presenting another celebration of the King’s musical genius, Coppola examines the imbalance of power within the relationship.

The glamour of Graceland gradually gives way to isolation, control and frustration.

It’s an intimate film about a young woman discovering that life alongside one of the world’s most famous entertainers can be deeply restrictive.

Children of Men (2006) — BBC One, 11.40pm

Alfonso Cuarón’s extraordinary dystopian drama imagines a future in which humanity has become infertile and society is collapsing.

Clive Owen plays Theo, a disillusioned former activist drawn into a dangerous mission to protect a young refugee.

The film’s images of authoritarian government, desperate migration, social breakdown and institutional cruelty have acquired an unsettling contemporary relevance.

Cuarón’s direction is remarkable, particularly the extended action sequences that place viewers directly inside the chaos.

Yet beneath the violence lies a profoundly humane argument about compassion and hope.

One of the finest science-fiction films of the twenty-first century.

Ernest Cole: Lost and Found (2024) — Channel 4, midnight, early Monday

Raoul Peck’s documentary tells the story of Ernest Cole, the South African photographer whose images exposed the brutality of apartheid.

Cole documented the everyday humiliations, restrictions and injustices imposed upon Black South Africans by the racist state.

His work was both artistic achievement and political testimony. It made visible a system that depended partly upon controlling what outsiders could see.

His photographs contributed to his exile, and much of his later life was marked by hardship and displacement.

Peck uses Cole’s remarkable archive to explore racial oppression, memory and the terrible personal costs that can accompany the pursuit of truth.

An important documentary about a photographer whose work deserves to be much better known.

Monday 19 October

Aberfan: The Village That Fought Back — BBC Two, 9pm; repeated Tuesday, 11pm

Sixty years after the Aberfan disaster, this documentary examines the struggle that followed the deaths of 144 people, including 116 children.

For the families, the nightmare did not end when the rescue operation finished.

They faced official resistance, evasions and an extraordinary struggle to have the remaining dangerous coal tips removed from above their village.

The disaster tribunal placed responsibility upon the National Coal Board, but securing practical justice proved another matter.

Particularly shameful was the pressure placed upon the Aberfan Disaster Fund to contribute towards the removal of the remaining tips. Money donated in sympathy for bereaved families was treated as a potential source of funding for work that public authorities should have undertaken.

This is not simply a historical account of industrial negligence. It’s about the relationship between ordinary people and powerful institutions, and the lengths those institutions may go to in order to avoid accountability.

The villagers’ persistence deserves recognition alongside the suffering they endured.

Essential viewing, and our most important television recommendation of the week.

Selma (2014) — BBC Two, 11.05pm

Ava DuVernay’s absorbing historical drama examines the 1965 campaign for voting rights in Alabama, culminating in the famous marches from Selma to Montgomery.

David Oyelowo is outstanding as Dr Martin Luther King Jr, capturing both his charisma and the enormous pressures of leadership.

The film avoids presenting the civil rights movement as a simple procession of heroic speeches and inevitable victories.

Instead, it explores the difficult strategic decisions, internal disagreements, state violence and extraordinary courage involved in challenging segregation.

Its depiction of collective action is particularly powerful.

Progress did not arrive because powerful people suddenly became generous. It came because ordinary people organised, protested and refused to accept injustice.

Priyo Maloti (2024) — Channel 4, South Asian film season; time to be confirmed

This Bangladeshi drama, directed by Shankha Dasgupta, stars Mehazabien Chowdhury in her feature-film debut.

She plays Maloti, a young pregnant woman whose life is devastated when her husband dies in a catastrophic fire.

What follows is a struggle to survive financially and emotionally in circumstances where support cannot always be taken for granted.

The film examines grief, insecurity and the vulnerability of those suddenly left to confront hardship alone.

It’s a welcome selection from Channel 4’s South Asian film season, which provides an opportunity to discover cinema beyond the industries and countries that usually dominate British film schedules.

Tuesday 20 October

Hot Fuzz (2007) — Film4, 9pm

Edgar Wright’s wonderfully inventive action-comedy stars Simon Pegg as Nicholas Angel, a London police officer whose extraordinary efficiency embarrasses his colleagues.

Transferred to the apparently peaceful Gloucestershire village of Sandford, he discovers that beneath the picturesque surface something decidedly sinister is happening.

Nick Frost is excellent as his enthusiastic but less disciplined partner, Danny Butterman.

The film affectionately mocks the conventions of Hollywood action movies while delivering a wonderfully sharp satire of small-town respectability, authoritarianism and the desire to preserve appearances at any cost.

Its rapid editing, visual jokes and lovingly constructed action sequences reward repeated viewing.

One of the finest British comedies of its generation.

Stacey Dooley: Down the K-Hole — BBC Three, 9pm; BBC One, 10.40pm

Stacey Dooley at the National TV Awards 2019 at the O2 Arena, London.

Stacey Dooley investigates ketamine use and the growing concern surrounding the drug.

Originally developed as an anaesthetic and now also being researched and used in carefully controlled medical settings, ketamine has become increasingly prominent as a recreational substance.

Its effects can include dissociation and altered perception, while repeated heavy use can cause serious harm, particularly to the bladder and urinary system.

Dooley’s strength as a presenter is her willingness to speak to people without immediately passing judgement. That approach can be especially valuable when examining drug use, where moral condemnation often gets in the way of understanding.

An important subject deserving careful investigation.

Clickbait Clinic with Stacey Dooley: Can Blue Dye Make Me Smarter? — BBC One, 11.40pm

Stacey Dooley is certainly keeping herself busy.

Here she examines the growing enthusiasm for methylene blue, a substance with established medical uses that has also attracted attention for possible effects on brain function.

Some preliminary research has explored potential neurological applications, including areas relevant to Alzheimer’s disease, but that is a long way from demonstrating that healthy people can improve their intelligence by taking it.

The distinction between interesting scientific research and commercial exaggeration is crucial.

The programme should offer a useful examination of how tentative findings can become exaggerated promises in the world of online health trends.

Midnight Run (1988) — Film4, 11.25pm

Robert De Niro and Charles Grodin form one of cinema’s most enjoyable mismatched partnerships in this action-comedy directed by Martin Brest.

De Niro plays Jack Walsh, a bounty hunter tasked with bringing a former Mafia accountant across America.

Grodin plays the accountant, Jonathan Mardukas, whose apparently mild personality conceals a remarkable ability to frustrate his captor.

Their journey becomes increasingly chaotic as criminals, federal agents and competing bounty hunters join the pursuit.

The action is entertaining, but the real pleasure lies in the developing relationship between the two men.

A clever, funny film that knows exactly how to combine comedy with genuine character development.

Storyville: A Want in Her — BBC Four; time to be confirmed

Another documentary from the excellent Storyville strand, which has long been one of our favourites at Counter Culture.

This deeply personal film explores the complexities of caring for someone affected by mental illness and addiction.

Such relationships can involve extraordinary love and loyalty, but also exhaustion, resentment and an overwhelming sense of helplessness.

The challenge for documentary filmmaking is to acknowledge these difficult feelings without reducing the person experiencing illness or addiction to a problem that needs solving.

Storyville has built its reputation by presenting demanding subjects with intelligence, honesty and humanity.

Its documentaries regularly demonstrate why independent filmmaking remains so important.

Wednesday 21 October

Caligula’s Hidden Legacy — PBS America, 7.05pm (1/2)

The Roman emperor Caligula has entered popular imagination as the embodiment of cruelty, extravagance and madness.

But how much do we actually know about him?

Many of the surviving accounts were written by historians hostile to his rule, raising questions about the accuracy of the more sensational stories.

This documentary investigates the historical figure behind the notorious reputation.

Ancient Rome remains endlessly fascinating partly because its politics, ambitions and struggles for power can appear so familiar.

A useful opportunity to distinguish historical evidence from the legends accumulated over centuries.

The World’s End (2013) — Film4, 9pm

Edgar Wright reunites Simon Pegg and Nick Frost for the final instalment of the celebrated Cornetto trilogy.

Five former friends return to their hometown in an attempt to recreate a legendary pub crawl from their youth.

Their reunion is complicated by the behaviour of Gary King, played by Pegg, a man who has never properly accepted that his teenage years are over.

What begins as a comedy about ageing, friendship and nostalgia becomes something rather more extraordinary when the group discovers that the town has changed in unexpected ways.

The science-fiction elements are entertaining, but beneath them lies a surprisingly affecting exploration of disappointment and the difficulty of moving on.

Alongside Tuesday’s Hot Fuzz, this provides an enjoyable opportunity to revisit two very different Edgar Wright comedies.

The Experiment — Channel 4, 10pm

Matt Fraser and Sophie Morgan invite ordinary people to participate in a social experiment within a new care facility.

The programme examines attitudes, behaviour and the relationships that develop when people are placed in an unfamiliar institutional environment.

There’s an interesting parallel with Netflix’s new Stanford Prison Experiment, which also begins with participants placed into assigned roles within a controlled setting.

The situations are different, but both invite us to consider how surroundings, expectations and power structures can influence behaviour.

The crucial question is whether people simply adapt to the roles given to them or retain the ability to challenge the assumptions underlying those roles.

Alison Steadman Remembers The Singing Detective — BBC Four, 10pm

Alison Steadman looks back at Dennis Potter’s extraordinary 1986 television drama, one of the most ambitious works ever produced for British television.

Potter combined psychological investigation, musical fantasy, detective fiction and autobiography to create something genuinely original.

Michael Gambon played Philip Marlow, a writer hospitalised with a debilitating skin condition whose memories and imagination become increasingly entangled.

The drama remains a testament to an era when British television was willing to take enormous creative risks.

The Singing Detective: Lovely Days, Stroke Clues — BBC Four, 10.15pm

An opportunity to revisit Potter’s masterpiece immediately after Alison Steadman’s introduction.

The series moves between Marlow’s hospital experiences, childhood memories and the imaginary detective story he has created.

Popular songs become part of an elaborate psychological landscape, while apparently unrelated incidents gradually reveal deeper connections.

Potter’s work demands attention, but the rewards are considerable.

Few television writers have explored the relationship between memory, illness, guilt and imagination with comparable originality.

Night of the Demon (1957) — Talking Pictures TV, 9.10pm

Jacques Tourneur’s classic supernatural horror follows an American psychologist investigating a mysterious cult led by the sinister Dr Julian Karswell.

Dana Andrews plays the sceptical investigator, while Niall MacGinnis gives a wonderfully unsettling performance as Karswell.

Based on M. R. James’s Casting the Runes, the film creates an atmosphere of growing dread.

Much of its effectiveness comes from the tension between rational explanation and the possibility that supernatural forces really do exist.

There has long been debate about the decision to show the demon itself, rather than leaving everything to the viewer’s imagination.

Whatever one’s view, the film remains one of the finest examples of British supernatural cinema.

Stacey Dooley: Rape on Trial — BBC Three, 11pm (1/2) and 11.50pm (2/2)

Stacey Dooley follows women who have reported being raped by men they know, examining the difficult and often lengthy journey towards trial.

The first programme introduces the women’s experiences and the challenges involved in pursuing their cases.

The second considers the approach of the trials, particularly the way complainants’ credibility may be scrutinised during proceedings.

These are sensitive and difficult subjects. The criminal justice system must protect the rights of defendants while also ensuring that complainants are treated fairly and respectfully.

The programme raises important questions about evidence, credibility, trauma and confidence in the justice process.

Another demanding assignment for Dooley, whose documentary work continues to cover an impressive range of subjects.

Thursday 22 October

Mercury Prize: Album of the Year — BBC Four, 9.30pm

The Mercury Prize returns to Newcastle, celebrating outstanding albums by British and Irish musicians.

Lauren Laverne hosts an evening featuring live performances from Florence + The Machine, Nia Archives, Kojey Radical, Olivia Dean, RAYE, Suede, JADE, Dove Ellis, Knats and Pulp, with the latter representing the charity album HELP(2).

This year’s shortlist also includes Paul McCartney’s The Boys of Dungeon Lane, Olivia Dean’s The Art of Loving and RAYE’s THIS MUSIC MAY CONTAIN HOPE.

Last year’s winner was Sam Fender, another artist with strong connections to the North East.

There’s something pleasing about the continued importance of the album in a musical world increasingly dominated by individual tracks, algorithms and streaming playlists.

Albums allow musicians to develop themes and create a sustained artistic experience. They can be ambitious, personal, experimental and occasionally difficult. That’s part of their appeal.

The Mercury Prize has often helped introduce audiences to performers they might otherwise have overlooked, while recognising established musicians who continue to take risks.

With so many acts performing live, the event promises to be much more than an awards ceremony. It’s effectively a miniature festival celebrating the continuing vitality of contemporary music.

Sweat (2020) — Film4, 1.40am, early Friday

Directed by Magnus von Horn, this Polish-Swedish drama follows Sylwia, a successful fitness instructor and social media influencer.

She has hundreds of thousands of followers, a carefully constructed public image and apparently everything needed for a glamorous modern life.

Yet behind the motivational videos and polished appearances lies a woman experiencing profound loneliness.

Magdalena Koleśnik gives an absorbing performance as Sylwia, whose online confidence conceals insecurity and emotional vulnerability.

The film examines the strange contradictions of social media celebrity, where the appearance of intimacy can coexist with a lack of meaningful personal relationships.

It’s an intelligent and uncomfortable portrait of a world in which being constantly visible does not necessarily mean being understood.

Friday 23 October

Sicily: The Conquered Isle — PBS America, 7.10pm and 8.30pm

Two programmes explore the remarkable history of Sicily, an island whose strategic position in the Mediterranean has made it a crossroads of civilisations.

The first, Crossroads of the Mediterranean, examines its ancient past and the succession of peoples who fought to control it.

Greeks, Romans, Arabs and Normans all left their mark, creating a distinctive cultural inheritance visible in the island’s architecture, traditions and historical monuments.

The second programme, Borderlands, explores Sicily’s role in the nineteenth-century unification of Italy.

The island’s history demonstrates how geography can shape politics and culture over thousands of years.

For anyone interested in European history, this should be rewarding viewing.

Billy Lynn’s Long Halftime Walk (2016) — Great Action, 9pm

Ang Lee’s drama follows a young American soldier who returns temporarily from Iraq after an act of battlefield heroism makes him a national celebrity.

Joe Alwyn plays Billy Lynn, whose experiences of combat contrast sharply with the patriotic spectacle organised around him.

The film examines the way soldiers are transformed into symbols and used to promote reassuring narratives about war.

Behind the ceremonies, applause and carefully staged celebrations lies a young man struggling with memories of violence and the reality of returning to combat.

Its anti-war message emerges from the gulf between public mythology and personal experience.

An interesting and thoughtful film about the exploitation of military heroism.

Disco Night — BBC Four, from 9.45pm; BBC iPlayer

BBC Four devotes the evening to disco, a musical movement that transformed popular culture.

For some, disco still conjures up images of mirror balls, extravagant clothing and dance-floor anthems. Yet its history is considerably more interesting than those familiar images suggest.

Emerging from Black, Latino and gay communities, particularly in American cities, disco became an expression of freedom, identity and collective enjoyment.

It also changed how records were produced, mixed and experienced.

The influence of disco can be heard throughout contemporary dance music, electronic pop and club culture.

A welcome opportunity to celebrate music that has sometimes been dismissed by critics who underestimated both its artistry and its cultural importance.

The Blackening (2022) — BBC Two, 11.30pm

This comedy horror follows a group of Black friends gathering at a remote woodland cabin to celebrate Juneteenth.

For British viewers unfamiliar with the occasion, Juneteenth commemorates 19 June 1865, when enslaved African Americans in Texas learned that emancipation was being enforced following the American Civil War. It has since become a major celebration of freedom and Black American history.

The film takes familiar horror conventions and turns them into a sharp comedy about race, stereotypes and representation.

One of its central jokes concerns the old horror-film convention in which Black characters are frequently among the first victims.

By placing an entirely Black group of friends at the centre of the story, the filmmakers gleefully undermine that convention.

The result is a mixture of horror, comedy and cultural satire.

Disco: Soundtrack of a Revolution — BBC Four, 12.15am, early Saturday

This documentary series explores disco’s origins, cultural significance and lasting influence.

Far from being merely a commercial musical craze, disco provided an important outlet for marginalised communities and helped create new spaces for social and personal expression.

Its history also involves the commercial music industry’s attempts to profit from an underground culture, and the backlash that followed its enormous success.

The opposition to disco sometimes carried racial and homophobic undertones, making its history inseparable from wider social struggles.

A valuable companion to BBC Four’s evening of disco celebrations.

I Was a Teenage Sex Pistol — Sky Arts, 1am, early Saturday

The emergence of the Sex Pistols in the mid-1970s helped transform British popular music and youth culture.

Their brief but explosive career challenged the musical establishment, attacked social conventions and gave expression to the anger and frustration of a generation.

Punk was never simply about musical ability or even musical style. It was also an attitude, a rejection of established hierarchies and an assertion that young people could create their own culture.

This documentary revisits that extraordinary moment and the personalities at its centre.

The Public Image Is Rotten — Sky Arts, 2.50am, early Saturday

John Lydon’s career did not end when the Sex Pistols disintegrated.

With Public Image Ltd, he moved into far more experimental musical territory, combining elements of post-punk, dub, electronic music and avant-garde experimentation.

This documentary examines the band’s turbulent history and Lydon’s determination to resist easy categorisation.

There’s an interesting contrast with BBC Four’s disco celebrations. Disco and punk were often treated as opposing movements, yet both challenged musical conventions and created new cultural possibilities.

Lydon has remained an abrasive and unpredictable figure, but Public Image Ltd’s contribution to the development of post-punk deserves recognition.

A suitably unconventional conclusion to the week’s musical television.


Streaming

Netflix

Fading Grandeur — All six episodes available Friday 23 October

This Spanish comedy drama explores the tensions between appearance and reality, drawing upon the familiar attractions of family relationships, social embarrassment and personal ambition.

Spanish television has developed an impressive reputation for combining comedy and drama, often finding humour in situations that are far from comfortable.

A six-part series should provide enough room to develop its characters without unnecessarily stretching the story.

The New Stanford Prison Experiment — All six episodes available Wednesday 21 October

Does power corrupt?

That is the central question behind this new Netflix social experiment, which places thirty participants inside a real prison and randomly assigns them the roles of guards or prisoners.

The programme deliberately recalls the notorious Stanford Prison Experiment conducted in California in 1971.

Psychologist Philip Zimbardo and his colleagues recruited male college students and placed them in a simulated prison environment. Some were assigned the role of guards, others prisoners.

The study was supposed to last up to two weeks but was abandoned after just six days amid disturbing behaviour and psychological distress.

For many years, it was presented as evidence that ordinary people could rapidly become abusive when placed in positions of unchecked authority.

However, the original experiment has subsequently faced serious criticism. Researchers have questioned the way participants were instructed, the influence of expectations upon their behaviour and the validity of the conclusions drawn from the results.

The new Netflix programme uses a real prison setting, a mixed-gender group of participants and additional ethical safeguards.

It will be interesting to compare the findings with the original study, while remembering that this is also a television production intended to entertain.

Power certainly influences behaviour, but the relationship between authority, obedience and individual responsibility is more complicated than the old Stanford experiment sometimes suggested.

One of the week’s most intriguing streaming choices.

Judge John Deed — All 29 episodes available Saturday 17 October

Martin Shaw stars as Sir John Deed, a High Court judge whose determination to follow his conscience regularly brings him into conflict with the judicial establishment and political authorities.

Originally broadcast by the BBC between 2001 and 2007, the drama combines courtroom cases with political intrigue and personal complications.

Shaw brings considerable authority to the central role, making Deed an engaging if occasionally exasperating character.

The series is also interesting for its depiction of tensions between law, justice and institutional pressure.

Legal professionals may sometimes find themselves questioning the dramatic liberties taken with courtroom procedure, but the programme remains entertaining and frequently thought-provoking.

Channel 4 Streaming

Walter Presents: When the Night Comes — All six episodes available Friday 23 October

In an apparently idyllic seaside town, Stephanie wakes to the horrifying realisation that she has been raped in her own home.

The crime shatters her sense of security and exposes tensions beneath the community’s peaceful exterior.

The six-part drama explores the consequences of sexual violence, the search for truth and the difficulties faced by those attempting to rebuild their lives.

The Walter Presents collection continues to provide British viewers with access to international drama that might otherwise remain relatively unknown.

Its willingness to tackle demanding subjects has made it one of the most worthwhile streaming collections available.

Prime Video

The Last Viking — Available now

Anders Thomas Jensen directs this Danish black comedy starring Nikolaj Lie Kaas and Mads Mikkelsen.

Kaas plays Anker, a bank robber who entrusts stolen money to his brother Manfred before serving fifteen years in prison.

When Anker is finally released, he discovers that Manfred has developed serious psychiatric difficulties, believes himself to be John Lennon and no longer remembers where the money was hidden.

What follows is an increasingly bizarre attempt to recover the missing fortune.

Jensen has a gift for combining dark humour with damaged characters and unexpected emotional depth.

Mikkelsen is particularly well suited to this kind of material, bringing both intensity and comic unpredictability to his performances.

An unusual mixture of crime story, family drama and eccentric comedy.

BBC iPlayer

Smiley’s People — Available now

Sir Alec Guinness returns as George Smiley in this acclaimed BBC adaptation of John le Carré’s Cold War thriller, first broadcast in 1982.

Following the success of Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy, the series once again immerses viewers in a world of espionage, deception, old loyalties and deeply compromised individuals.

Guinness’s performance is a masterclass in restraint. His Smiley is outwardly unremarkable, but beneath the quiet manner lies an extraordinary intelligence and a formidable capacity for investigation.

Unlike the glamorous spies of popular adventure fiction, le Carré’s characters inhabit a morally ambiguous world in which personal betrayal and political calculation are inseparable.

One of the finest achievements of British television drama, and a perfect companion to this week’s Radio 4 Extra adaptation of Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy.

Alex Jones: Un Diwrnod yn Aberfan (One Day in Aberfan) — Available Sunday 18 October

This Welsh-language programme forms part of the commemorations marking sixty years since the Aberfan disaster.

On 21 October 1966, a collapsing colliery spoil tip engulfed Pantglas Junior School and surrounding houses, killing 144 people, including 116 children.

The tragedy remains a defining moment in the history of Welsh mining communities.

Commemorative programmes such as this are particularly important because they preserve personal memories and ensure that the experiences of those affected are not reduced to statistics.

The disaster also raises enduring questions about industrial responsibility, the treatment of working-class communities and the failure of powerful institutions to listen to warnings.

An essential companion to Monday’s BBC Two documentary, Aberfan: The Village That Fought Back.

Paramount+

Treasure Island — Episode 2 available Monday 19 October

The latest adaptation of Robert Louis Stevenson’s classic adventure features David Oyelowo as Long John Silver.

The original novel remains one of the defining works of adventure fiction, introducing generations of readers to pirates, buried treasure, betrayal and the dangerous attraction of the high seas.

Long John Silver is the story’s great achievement: charismatic, resourceful, manipulative and morally ambiguous.

A successful adaptation needs to capture both his charm and the threat concealed beneath it.

Oyelowo is an interesting choice for the role, and the series offers an opportunity to introduce Stevenson’s enduring characters to another generation.

HBO Max

The Narco Hack — All three episodes available Friday 23 October

This three-part documentary tells the extraordinary story of Sky ECC, an encrypted messaging service that became popular among organised crime networks.

The attraction was simple. Subscribers believed that their communications were protected by encryption powerful enough to prevent the authorities from reading their messages.

For criminal organisations, that apparent security made it possible to conduct business with a confidence that would otherwise have been impossible.

In 2021, however, investigators led by French authorities succeeded in compromising the system, exposing communications that provided unprecedented insights into criminal networks.

The documentary examines the technological operation and its consequences.

It’s a fascinating illustration of the increasingly sophisticated struggle between organised crime and law enforcement, as well as the wider questions raised by encrypted communications, privacy and surveillance.


Radio

Sunday 18 October

Childline — BBC Radio 4, 1.30pm

Forty years after Esther Rantzen launched Childline in 1986, this programme examines the organisation’s remarkable history.

Childline was founded upon a simple but enormously important principle: children experiencing abuse, distress or fear needed somewhere they could turn for confidential support.

In the decades that followed, the service helped countless young people who might otherwise have remained unheard.

The programme has acquired additional poignancy following Rantzen’s death in September.

She was an influential broadcaster, but her work establishing Childline may prove to be her most enduring achievement.

It’s a reminder that the value of a public life is not simply measured by celebrity or professional success, but by the practical difference someone makes to others.

A fitting tribute to an important legacy.

The Mysterious Case of Annie Elizabeth — BBC Radio 4, 7.15pm

For history enthusiasts, this intriguing programme investigates the story behind Annie Elizabeth, a variety of apple with an unusually personal name.

Who was Annie Elizabeth, and why did an apple come to bear her name?

It’s the kind of apparently obscure historical question that can lead to unexpected discoveries about the people and communities of the past.

There is something rather appealing about the way ordinary objects can preserve human stories long after the people involved have disappeared.

A gentle but potentially fascinating piece of historical detective work.

Monday 19 October

Book of the Week: Stalin’s Apostles — BBC Radio 4, 11.45am; late repeat 12.30am

An adaptation of Antonia Senior’s book about the Cambridge Five spy ring.

Kim Philby, Guy Burgess, Donald Maclean, Anthony Blunt and John Cairncross became Soviet agents despite occupying positions of considerable privilege within British society.

Their activities exposed the vulnerability of an establishment that relied heavily upon personal connections, class background and assumptions about loyalty.

The story remains fascinating because it involves conflicting allegiances, ideological conviction, personal ambition and extraordinary betrayal.

It also provides an interesting historical companion to our television and streaming selections featuring John le Carré’s fictional world of espionage.

How Houdini Made Magic with Derren Brown — BBC Radio 4, Monday to Friday, 1.45pm

Derren Brown examines the life and extraordinary achievements of Harry Houdini, one of the most celebrated entertainers of the twentieth century.

Houdini became famous for his astonishing escapes from handcuffs, locked containers and seemingly impossible situations.

Yet his achievements were not simply physical feats. They also relied upon psychology, showmanship, misdirection and an understanding of audience expectations.

Perhaps most interestingly, Houdini later became a determined critic of fraudulent spiritualists, exposing techniques used to convince grieving people that mediums could communicate with the dead.

Brown is an ideal guide, possessing both practical knowledge of illusion and a fascination with the psychology of belief.

A promising series about entertainment, deception and the boundary between what we see and what we think we see.

The Essay: John Foxx — Key Moments — BBC Radio 3, 9.45pm

John Foxx, the original frontman of Ultravox, reflects upon five pianos that have played important roles in his life.

Foxx was a significant figure in the emergence of British electronic music, helping establish the foundations of what later became known as synth-pop and new wave.

After leaving Ultravox, he developed a distinctive solo career, combining electronic experimentation with atmospheric, often introspective songwriting.

His reflections upon the piano offer an interesting contrast with his reputation as an electronic music pioneer.

The relationship between traditional musical instruments and modern technology has always been more complicated than the familiar opposition between acoustic and electronic music suggests.

For those interested in the development of modern British popular music, this should be particularly rewarding.

Tuesday 20 October

Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy — BBC Radio 4 Extra, 6am, 11am and 5pm

A radio adaptation of John le Carré’s 1974 Cold War thriller.

George Smiley is drawn out of retirement to investigate the possibility that a Soviet mole has infiltrated the highest levels of British intelligence.

The story is a masterpiece of deception, suspicion and psychological investigation.

Its world is far removed from the glamorous adventures of James Bond. Le Carré’s spies are frequently tired, disappointed and morally compromised individuals operating within bureaucratic institutions.

This adaptation was originally broadcast in 1988, nine years after the celebrated BBC television version starring Alec Guinness.

With Smiley’s People also available on BBC iPlayer this week, there is an opportunity to explore two of le Carré’s finest stories in different formats.

His novels remain among the most intelligent examinations of espionage, loyalty and betrayal ever written for a popular audience.


Final Thoughts

There is a particularly strong historical and political thread running through this week’s choices.

Aberfan reminds us of the terrible consequences of institutional negligence and the determination of ordinary people to secure justice. Selma examines the struggle for civil rights, while Ernest Cole: Lost and Found demonstrates the power of photography to expose oppression.

The Day the Earth Stood Still and Billy Lynn’s Long Halftime Walk approach the subjects of war and peace from very different directions. Both invite us to question the comforting narratives that societies construct around violence.

Meanwhile, The New Stanford Prison Experiment and Channel 4’s The Experiment ask questions about power, authority and human behaviour.

Music is particularly well served, from the harmonies of the Everly Brothers to the experimental work of John Foxx, the Mercury Prize, disco and punk.

And there’s plenty of room for entertainment that makes fewer demands: Hitchcock’s magnificent North by Northwest, Edgar Wright’s comedies and the eccentric delights of The Addams Family.

That’s what makes a good week’s viewing. There should be opportunities to learn, to think, to be challenged and, occasionally, simply to enjoy ourselves.

Enjoy the week.

Selections and reviews by Pat Harrington

 

 

Leave a Comment

Culture Vulture: 10–16 October 2026

Leave a Comment

The Mentalist, Season 1 Episode 3: Red Tide Review

Spoilers!

One of the smartest decisions The Mentalist makes early in its run is refusing to treat murder as a puzzle alone.

Many procedural dramas are ultimately interested in mechanics. A body appears. Clues are collected. Suspects are interviewed. A culprit is identified. Case closed.

Red Tide, the third episode of the series, understands that crime rarely begins with logic. More often, it begins with emotion.

Fear. Jealousy. Loneliness. Anger. The desperate need to belong.

Set against the sun-drenched backdrop of California’s surfing culture, Red Tide exchanges the vineyards and small-town politics of the previous episode for a world of teenagers, secrets and shifting loyalties. It is a quieter hour than the pilot or Red Hair and Silver Tape, lacking a larger-than-life antagonist or dramatic set pieces, but it compensates with atmosphere and emotional intelligence.

The result is one of the first episodes that reveals the real strength of The Mentalist: its understanding of people.

The case begins when the body of a teenage girl named Kelly is discovered washed up on a beach. The tragedy sends shockwaves through her close-knit surfing community, yet the response from her friends immediately feels unusual. There is grief, certainly, but also hesitation. Conversations end abruptly. Eyes shift nervously. Information is withheld.

Patrick Jane notices it immediately.

As always, Simon Baker makes observation feel more interesting than action. Jane arrives at a scene and sees patterns not in physical evidence but in behaviour. While others search for fingerprints and motives, he studies reactions. His attention drifts not to what people are saying but to what they are desperately trying not to say.

This approach is particularly effective among teenagers.

Adults, when they lie, often have a strategy. Teenagers rarely do.

Their lies emerge from panic. Embarrassment. Loyalty to friends. Fear of authority. Fear of exclusion.

Red Tide understands this distinction and builds its investigation around it.

Rather than treating the young suspects like criminals, Jane treats them like confused adolescents caught in circumstances beyond their control. It is one of the earliest examples of the show’s empathy, and one of the reasons Patrick Jane remains such an engaging character.

He never talks down to them.

He doesn’t try desperately to appear younger than he is. He doesn’t force trust. He simply listens.

There’s a natural ease to the way Jane moves through the surfing community. He sits with the teenagers, asks seemingly casual questions and quietly observes the social currents moving beneath every interaction.

Soon, a familiar pattern emerges.

There are leaders and followers.

There are insiders and outsiders.

There are those who are confident and those terrified of losing their place within the group. Like a detective mapping a crime scene, Jane maps relationships. The episode becomes less about solving a murder and more about understanding a community.

That community is beautifully realised. The surfers could easily have become stereotypes, but the writing gives them just enough depth to feel authentic. They are impulsive and emotional, but also vulnerable. Their friendships feel real. Their fears feel real. Even their silences reveal something important.

The beach setting helps enormously.

The California coastline has often been romanticised in film and television as a place of freedom, youth and possibility. Red Tide cleverly uses that imagery while revealing the tension lurking underneath. Beneath the open skies and crashing waves is a network of secrets held together by fragile trust.

The atmosphere is one of the episode’s greatest achievements.

There is a melancholy quality running through the story. The sea seems less a symbol of freedom than a reminder of uncertainty. Relationships drift. Reputations shift. Certainties disappear.

For a series best known for its wit, Red Tide is surprisingly thoughtful.

The episode also benefits from its portrayal of parents.

While the teenagers hide their fears from authority, the adults struggle with a different problem altogether: understanding the lives their children lead when nobody is watching.

Some parents are protective. Others appear distracted. Some are simply overwhelmed.

What unites them is a sense of helplessness.

The adults believe they know their children. The investigation gradually reveals how incomplete that understanding really is.

This tension between parents and children becomes one of the episode’s central themes. The emotional intensity of teenage life is frequently underestimated by adults. Relationships that seem trivial from the outside can feel all-consuming to the people experiencing them.

Jane recognises this.

Where others dismiss youthful feelings as melodrama, he treats them seriously.

That empathy becomes his greatest investigative tool.

Perhaps the most remarkable aspect of Red Tide is how gentle Jane’s methods are compared with previous episodes. There are fewer elaborate psychological traps and fewer moments of public humiliation for suspects. Instead, he works quietly, creating opportunities for people to tell the truth.

A conversation on a beach.

A carefully timed question.

A moment of silence that encourages somebody to keep talking.

Jane understands that frightened people often reveal more when they feel safe than when they feel pressured.

It’s a subtle distinction, but an important one.

The episode effectively demonstrates that Patrick Jane’s gift is not manipulation alone. It is understanding.

Robin Tunney’s Teresa Lisbon continues to develop impressively alongside him.

In many episodes, Lisbon serves as the practical counterbalance to Jane’s instincts, but Red Tide highlights another side of her personality. She is deeply protective, particularly when dealing with young people. Her priority is not simply closing the case but ensuring vulnerable teenagers are treated fairly throughout the investigation.

Tunney brings warmth to moments that could easily feel procedural.

Lisbon recognises the emotional damage surrounding the case and responds with a level of compassion that distinguishes her from many television detectives. Her willingness to trust Jane’s methods while maintaining clear boundaries continues to define one of television’s most enjoyable partnerships.

There is still friction between them.

There always will be.

Yet every episode strengthens the sense that they need one another. Jane supplies insight. Lisbon provides structure. Together they create a balance neither could achieve alone.

The eventual solution to the murder avoids sensationalism, which feels entirely appropriate.

This is not the story of a criminal mastermind or a calculated predator. Instead, it is a tragedy born from emotional instability, poor decisions and consequences that spiral beyond anyone’s control.

The revelation lands not because it is shocking but because it is sad.

That sadness lingers.

It reminds us that many crimes emerge not from evil but from ordinary human weakness.

By the time the credits roll, Red Tide has accomplished something deceptively difficult. It delivers a compelling mystery while deepening our understanding of Patrick Jane, Teresa Lisbon and the emotional foundations of the series itself.

The episode may not be among the most famous entries in The Mentalist’s seven-season run, but it remains one of its most quietly effective.

Atmospheric, compassionate and psychologically astute, Red Tide demonstrates that the series is at its best when it looks beyond the crime and focuses on the people left in its wake.

Sometimes solving a murder is the easy part.

Understanding why it happened is where the real story begins.

Reviewed by Chris Storton

Leave a Comment

Older Posts »