⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
The performance offers an intimate experience that stands apart. Its minimalist approach transforms it into a musical testimonial or a heartfelt confession set to melodies, veering away from the conventions of traditional musicals. The production exudes a blend of tenderness, candour, and a profoundly poignant beauty. Shaye Poulton Richards’ extraordinary talent shines brilliantly, infusing the narrative with both whimsy and melancholy. It’s a rarity for any musical to be so firmly rooted in reality, capturing life’s rawness alongside its small joys, a feat that Lies All The Way Down undeniably achieves.
Christy Gilbert and Emily Proudlock possess mellifluous voices that effortlessly fill the space and captivate the audience. Their performances are marked by emotional depth, conveying nuances through their vocal expressions and gestures. This imbues the already exquisite songs with added layers, while also infusing their distinctive personas into their respective roles.
The live band’s orchestration and music create an evocative atmosphere. With a simple yet intricate presentation, the musicians’ exceptional and flawless execution establishes an immediate personal connection, drawing the audience in swiftly.
The music in this production serves as a constant companion, akin to a cinematic experience with an ever-present soundtrack. The narrative revolves around two colleagues whose journey delves into confronting the falsehoods they both present to themselves and others. The integration of music into the storyline is executed seamlessly, enhancing the overall experience. The music itself is undeniably beautiful, to the point where it occasionally overshadows the lyrical and narrative components. While the story remains engaging, it’s the musical elements that truly shine.
However, it’s worth noting that the lyrical aspect didn’t always match the strength of the music. The songs, though pleasant, could have benefited from more compelling hooks to achieve a greater level of catchiness. Despite this minor criticism, the production is a must-see primarily for its musical prowess. While the theatrical aspect holds its own merits, it doesn’t quite reach the same level of exceptionalism as the musical components do.
All in all, Lies All The Way Down stands as an unusual and bold experiment, pushing the boundaries of what a musical can be. This unique approach makes it worth seeing on many levels, from its intimate storytelling to its captivating melodies, showcasing a remarkable blend of vulnerability and artistic boldness.
Reviewed by Patrick Harrington
Venue 9
theSpace @ Niddry St – Upper Theatre (Thrust)
19:10
Aug 23-26
50 minutes
Suitability: 14+ (Guideline)
Country: United Kingdom – England
Group: Shaye Poulton Richards
Warnings and additional info: Contains distressing or potentially triggering themes