Paperlight Theatre’s Caligari takes the 1920 silent film The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari and reshapes it into something strange, witty, and unsettling. It keeps the expressionist spirit of the original but adds humour, modern touches, and a knowing edge. What might have been a simple retelling becomes a theatrical experiment that unsettles and amuses in equal measure.
The performers involve the audience from the beginning. They break the fourth wall, step out of character, and share the mechanics of the play. For many this gave the show a fresh spark, a sense of intimacy. For others it may have felt jarring. But it worked, for me, as a way of pulling us into the bizarre world being created. The police were played for laughs, bumbling, ineffective, figures of satire, which added to the sense of rebellion and increased the sense of helplessness and drift.
The piece did not lose sight of its darker roots. The theme of circularity ran through it, with characters repeating themselves as though trapped in a nightmare loop. This echoed the unease of the original film and gave the show a dreamlike, haunting quality. Yet one weakness was the depiction of Caligari himself. In the film his obsession was clear, half-academic curiosity, half madness. Here his motivation was less sharp, leaving a gap at the centre. Nonetheless, Tyler Raines delivers a chilling glimpse of a manipulative mad man.
Even with that flaw, the staging was inventive, the play of light and shadow effective, and the cast strong. The whole thing had a surreal atmosphere, laced with comedy and unease. You leave amused and unsettled, with the sense that the madness and manipulation of Caligari is not so far from our own time. It is more than homage—it is a clever, memorable reinvention of a classic story, well suited to the spirit of the Fringe.
Reviewed by Pat Harrington
More information and tickets here
