Official UK trailer Altitude Films. Watch on YouTube if the player does not load.
There is a moment in La Bola Negra when a young man learns that he is not welcome in the respectable society into which he was born. Nobody needs to shout at him or threaten him. A little black ball does the job. The members of an exclusive Granada club have voted against admitting him. They know, or think they know, that he is homosexual, and that is quite enough.
It is 1932. Carlos (Milo Quifes) comes from a prosperous family, and his father regards membership of the club as one of those things a young man of their standing ought to have. But money and family connections can only take him so far. A supposedly civilised institution has found a polite way of telling him he doesn’t belong. I couldn’t help thinking how much cruelty can be carried out by people who pride themselves on their good manners.
This is one of three stories told in La Bola Negra, the new film from Javier Calvo and Javier Ambrossi, better known as Los Javis. The action moves between 1932, the Spanish Civil War in 1937, and 2017, when a family inheritance begins to unlock secrets from the past. The film actually opens in wartime before taking us back to Carlos, and it moves between its periods rather than presenting them as three separate chapters.
In 1937 Sebastián (Guitarricadelafuente), a young trumpeter serving with Franco’s Nationalist forces, is assigned to guard Rafael Rodríguez Rapún (Miguel Bernardeau), a wounded Republican prisoner. Rafael had been the lover of the murdered poet Federico García Lorca. He is an enemy as far as the military authorities are concerned, someone to be watched and controlled. Sebastián, meanwhile, is supposed to obey orders and get on with his duties. Instead, he finds himself increasingly drawn to the prisoner.
Their conversations and small acts of consideration gradually become something more. There is no comfortable place for a relationship like this to develop. The two men are on opposite sides of a brutal war and their positions are anything but equal. Sebastián is wearing the uniform of the people holding Rafael captive. He may be able to offer kindness, but he cannot wish away the machinery of war around them.
Then we jump to 2017. Alberto (Carlos González), a historian with a partner and a life that would have been almost unimaginable to Carlos and Sebastián, discovers that his grandfather has left him an unexpected inheritance. It includes material associated with Lorca’s unfinished play La Bola Negra. Alberto starts digging into his family history and asking the sort of questions earlier generations preferred to leave unanswered. Quite why these three lives are connected is something the film allows us to discover, and I won’t spoil that.

Official La Bola Negra poster.
For me the strongest part is the relationship between Sebastián and Rafael. Guitarricadelafuente makes Sebastián awkward, uncertain and, at times, rather touching. He is not a fully formed rebel waiting for the right person to awaken him. He is a young man who finds that what he feels for Rafael doesn’t fit the duties and beliefs he has been taught to accept. That is far more interesting.
Nor is Rafael simply there to be loved. He has his own past, his own loyalties and the memory of Lorca. Miguel Bernardeau gives him a warmth and dignity which make it easy to understand Sebastián’s attraction. Some of the most affecting moments involve very little being said. A look held for just a little too long, a gesture of care: things which would be unremarkable between lovers in ordinary circumstances become dangerous here.
I did, however, want more of the politics. Sebastián and Rafael stand on opposite sides of the Spanish Civil War, arguably one of the defining ideological struggles of the twentieth century. What did Sebastián believe about the Nationalist cause? How much did he accept of the conservative Catholic order associated with it? And what did Rafael make of the man who was guarding him?
I’m not asking for a lecture on fascism, socialism or the failings of the Spanish Republic. A private conversation would have done it. Perhaps the two could have talked about their families, or what sort of Spain they hoped to see when the fighting stopped. Differences in belief are often revealed more clearly in ordinary exchanges than in grand speeches. The film gives us plenty about the dangers of forbidden love but rather less about how political conviction and personal affection might clash.
There is also a broader point about the pressure to conform. The club that rejects Carlos represents one face of that pressure; the military and religious world surrounding Sebastián represents a much harsher one. In both cases people are expected to behave in approved ways, and the consequences of stepping out of line can be severe. Church influence and social respectability are not exactly the same as a dictatorship, of course, but the film is persuasive in showing how they can reinforce each other.
Where I part company slightly with its message is in the suggestion that everybody must be completely open about who they are in order to live properly. I understand the argument. It is a terrible thing to feel obliged to conceal someone you love. But circumstances matter. A man living in Franco’s Spain, or fearing denunciation in a small conservative community, is not in the position of somebody living in Madrid in 2017. Sometimes keeping a secret is not cowardice or self-hatred. It is how you stay alive, keep a job or protect someone else.
I don’t think we should judge people of the past too readily by the freedoms we enjoy now. Nor am I convinced that being entirely open is always the only honest way of living. People are complicated. They make compromises, some wise and some disastrous. I would have liked the film to be a little less certain on this point.
Alberto’s modern story interests me for a different reason. As a historian he spends his working life trying to understand the past, yet part of his own family history has remained hidden from him. There is a nice irony there. We can know all sorts of things about kings, wars and political movements and still have little idea what our grandparents did, feared or concealed. A dusty manuscript can tell a story that no family member ever thought fit to mention.
This is also where the film’s treatment of Lorca works best. His murder in 1936 robbed Spain of a remarkable literary voice. He has never quite been silenced, of course; the poetry and plays remain. But what was never written, what was destroyed, and what people were frightened to preserve? We will never know the full extent. The film imagines one way in which an apparently lost work might reach across generations.
Visually, I thought the film was often magnificent. The lighting and colour deserve particular praise, not simply because individual shots look beautiful, but because the different periods have their own atmosphere. At times the images seem almost painted. At others the camera draws us uncomfortably close to a face or an exchange that the characters themselves would prefer to hide.
The snow scenes towards the end stayed with me. There is an extraordinary stillness about them which seems at odds with the turmoil we have seen. I would happily watch the film again just to follow how the images and the shifts in time work together. I suspect I missed a fair amount on a first viewing.
The supporting cast includes Penélope Cruz as the cabaret performer Nené and Glenn Close as Isabelle, a Lorca scholar. These appearances add colour to a film that is already rich in incident, and sometimes a little too rich. At roughly two hours and forty minutes it is a long watch, and occasionally I wished the directors would trust a scene and move on rather than elaborate further.
That said, I never felt the ambition was misplaced. There are films which can be enjoyed, discussed and forgotten between leaving the cinema and getting home. I don’t think this is one of them. I found myself returning to the question of how much of the past survives simply because somebody thought to keep a letter, a book or a few pages of writing.
I would recommend seeing La Bola Negra, although I’d be tempted to watch it at home when the opportunity arises. Not because its cinematography deserves a small screen — quite the opposite — but because the ability to pause and return to an earlier scene could be useful. This is one of those films where a second viewing might be more rewarding than the first.
It’s moving, occasionally frustrating, politically less searching than it might have been, and full of moments I won’t quickly forget. Sebastián and Rafael in particular stayed with me. So did that black ball: a small, ordinary object used to tell somebody that he is not ‘one of us’.
Reviewed by Patrick Harrington
Official La Bola Negra Poster By Movistar Plus+ — original source (Infobae). Fair use; Wikimedia/Wikipedia reference.
Leave a Reply