Posts Tagged Sylvester Stallone

I Play Rocky – Film Review by Anthony C Green

After the meta-complexity of Digger in my last trip to the cinema, which I’m still wrestling with weeks later, it was great to sit back and enjoy a great old fashioned regs-to-riches story that knew exactly how and when to manipulate the emotions of its audience. It’s a film that did exactly as you’d expect it to do, and if you’re a fan of the original Rocky movie, as I am, it’s a movie that really can’t miss, and it doesn’t.

Plot

As you’d expect, it’s a movie concerned with the making of Rocky, a film that earned the previously unknown Sylvester Stallone Oscar nominations for both best actor and best screenplay writer back in 1976, a golden double not achieved since Orson Wells for Citizen Kane way back in 1948.

The year of Rocky was also the year of America’s two-hundredth birthday celebrations, and drew heavily on the myth of the American Dream. This year’s damp squid of its two-hundred and fiftieth shows that that dream of ‘anybody can make it if they work hard enough’ has now faded into near nothingness, but I Play Rocky is a powerful reminder of a more confident time when, even if the myth really was never anything more than a myth, it was at least a myth that a sizeable number of people believed. The success of Rocky was down to many factors, but that it came along at just the right time was surely an important one, and one that, and this is one of my few criticisms, I Play…could perhaps have made more.

The film draws heavily on the parallel between how, in Rocky, a no-hope club fighter took his one chance at the big time through an unexpected title fight against brash World Heavyweight Champion Apollo Creed and seized it with both fists, and how the equally obscure bit-part actor cum aspirant screenplay writer Stallone and his struggled to create and get his movie made. Most of all, it’s about Stallone’s obstinance in insisting that he would play the lead.

$360,000 is a lot of money, raising steadily from an initial $25000, to step aside in favour of a ‘Star’, especially when your girlfriend is pregnant and you’re so poor that you’re reduced to selling your dog. But every time the fee for essentially doing nothing rises, he responds with the refrain that gives the movie its title: ‘I Play Rocky.’

It’s a good title, but if even half of what we see on screen here is true, it could just as easily have been called ‘I Am Rocky, because that’s who Stallone was at the time, a real life Rocky taking his chance, staying true to himself, and rising from a big nothing, to a great something.

History was to show that Stallone was one hundred percent to put principle above immediate money in the bank because, as we know, Rocky gave rise to a massive franchise, and would soon lead to Sly securing the lead in another massive franchise, the Rambo series, becoming, for a time, and arguably still today, one of the biggest movie stars on the planet. Counter Culture has also reviewed Stallone alongside Arnold Schwarzenegger in Escape Plan (2013).

Themes and Legends

After already having a few screenplays, laboriously two-finger typed by his ever loyal and loving girlfriend Sasha rejected, Stallone’s inspiration for the writing of Rocky, which according to this movie he knocked out the first draft of in three-and-a-half sleepless days and nights, came after he sat in a bar and watched real-life Heavyweight no-hoper Chuck Wepner (himself the subject of a decent film called The Bleeder) challenge the great Muhamad Ali, fresh of his shock KO win over George Foreman to regain the title. Wepner gave it is all, lasting into the 15th and final round before getting stopped. He even scored a ninth-round knockdown, one of only four fighters to floor Ali, even if the footage does clearly show that Ali was unbalanced when caught with a right-hander, after the ungainly Wepner stood on his foot.

This origin’s story for the Rocky script has been called into question, but if it’s more legend than truth, I don’t much care.

One thing I always liked about the first Rocky film, as a boxing fan, and increasingly over the years as a film fan, is that, like Wepner, he didn’t win. He won by taking everything the best fighter in the world could throw at him and was still standing at the end (or nearly the end, in Chuck’s case). It doesn’t say this in I Play…., but I’m sure that at some point some movie hotshot would have said, ‘But Rocky has to win! A knockout in the last seconds of the 15th, it’s the perfect fairytale ending!’ No, it wouldn’t, it would have been cliched rubbish, and if this was suggested, then Sly was right to resist, just as he was right not to countenance anybody but himself in the lead role: Burt Reynolds/Ryan O’Neil/Robert Redford, the names in the frame, as Rocky? No.

Cast and Crew

Ippolito naturally dominates, and has Stallone down to a tee. If you wanted to be picky, you could argue that it’s more of an impression than anything, but how else could he play it? Sly is much more intelligent than he’s given credit for, and that comes across in the film, but he’s not a man who lends himself to subtle reinterpretation. Mark Kermode’s review informed me that Ippolito gives a performance of similar mimetic excellence as Al Pacino in The Offer, a mini-series about the making of The Godfather, and as I’ve since discovered it’s available on ITVX, I’ll soon be checking that out for myself.

It’s not a big-name cast, or maybe I’m just out of touch, but they’re pretty much uniformly excellent, and it would be unfair to single anyone out, though I particularly enjoyed Robert Morgan’s all-too brief turn as the great Burgess Meredith, who played Rocky’s trainer Mickey in the original film, and some of the earlier sequels. Also excellent are AnnSophie Rabb as girlfriend and soon-to-be Stallone’s first wife Sasha, and Stephan James as Carl Weathers playing Apollo Creed.

(Thinking about it, as many of the actors are playing actors playing other characters, I suppose there are meta-aspects to this film too, though it’s certainly not as multi-layered as Digger)

Matt Dillon is probably the biggest name on display after Ippolito, but I thought the character he played, Sly’s tough-love dad Frank, was one of the weaker aspects of the film. That’s not reflection on Dillon, who does fine with what he is given, but he isn’t quite written as enough as a bastard to justify his implied reputation in the film.

Like Rocky, I Play…is not a big budget movie, and the look and style of the film are fully in keeping with its subject matter, as it should be. Full credit to Director Peter Farrelly for that.

It’s only showing in selected cinemas, but I’m sure it’ll find a wide and appreciative audience once it hits a major streaming service.

If I have a major criticism, it’s that the actual ‘Making Of…’ section of the film, after Rocky goes into production, is perhaps a tad long, and maybe fifteen minutes or so could have been shaved off the total 128-minute run-time here.

Having said that, some of the technical details concerning how they were able to make such a great movie in barely more than a month for a mere million dollars were very interesting. This is especially true of the use of ‘Steady-Cam’ equipment for the first time in what would become a major movie, after being pioneered on Sessame Street (and operated by the same guy in Rocky). This was a decision born of necessity, to save time having to move bulky camera, lighting etc equipment from location to location. But it was to prove crucial to the final luck and feel of the finished product. I’ve enjoyed all of the sequels to one degree or another, but, given a near unlimited budget through the success of the original, they lack the gritty, indie authenticity of that first film.

The scene depicting the creation of the iconic moment when Rocky runs up the steps of the Philadelphia Museum of Modern Art, was perhaps the highlight of I Play…

Conclusion

I gather that Stallone played no part in the making of his movie, and has been guarded in his responses to it, perhaps because part of the price he had to pay for getting to be Rocky was to be deprived of any right of ownership to the character. But he comes across as a decent, moral, determined individual who, like his greatest creation, overcame overwhelming odds to achieve his dream. And it made me want to watch Rocky again.

He couldn’t really ask for more than that.

Anthony C Green, November 2026

Poster image: I Play Rocky (2026), © Amazon MGM Studios / Amazon Content Services LLC. Poster artwork used for film-review identification and commentary. Image sourced via TMDB; see also the film’s Wikipedia entry.

Leave a Comment