Posts Tagged Chris de Burgh

Christmas with a Twist: Punk, Pop, Rock and a Spaceman | Christmas Special One

Welcome to the first Midweek Song List at the Weekend. Yes, it is only the middle of November, but Christmas has a habit of creeping up on us and we thought we would get in first. Over six weekend specials, we’ll explore Christmas music that goes well beyond the same handful of songs played in supermarkets.

This opening selection brings together fifteen recordings, from Chuck Berry’s rock and roll and the Beatles having fun to pop-punk, disco, shimmering alternative rock and an unusually thoughtful visitor from outer space. There are old favourites, versions you might never have heard and a few surprises. Not everything is mistletoe and merriment, either: some of the best Christmas records are about absence, frustration or longing.

We have included three versions of Please Come Home for Christmas for comparison. Listen to Charles Brown, Bon Jovi and Michael Bublé back to back and decide for yourself which works best. There are videos below each song’s story and a few thoughts about why we picked it.

1. Amasic — Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer

Rudolph began life as a character created by Robert L. May for an American department store in 1939. Johnny Marks turned the story into a song ten years later, and Gene Autry helped make it a Christmas favourite. It has since survived every imaginable treatment, from sentimental crooning to loud guitars.

For our opener, the Canadian pop-punk outfit Amasic give the reindeer a lively makeover. There is something rather cheering about a young band taking a tune everyone knows and attacking it with such obvious enthusiasm. Their performance is playful, energetic and, mercifully, not too reverential. A good way to start.

2. The Beatles — Christmas Time (Is Here Again)

Before Christmas records became another competitive branch of the pop industry, the Beatles made seasonal messages for members of their fan club. This gloriously repetitive song comes from their 1967 Christmas recording, with the band enjoying the opportunity to be silly away from the demands of another polished single.

It is hardly one of the great Lennon–McCartney compositions, and it does not pretend to be. That is half its appeal. The voices, jokes and sheer exuberance remind us of four musicians who could make even a festive throwaway sound unmistakably like the Beatles.

3. Chuck Berry — Run Rudolph Run

Released in 1958, this is the moment when Rudolph stopped plodding along at the pace of a traditional Christmas singalong and discovered rock and roll. Chuck Berry’s ringing guitar and driving rhythm brought the sound of teenage America straight into the seasonal songbook.

Berry doesn’t change his approach much for Christmas, and why should he? The guitar is sharp, the pace is frantic and the whole thing seems built for someone who has left the Christmas shopping far too late. Still one of the most enjoyable seasonal rockers.

4. Blink-182 — I Won’t Be Home for Christmas

Christmas songs tend to celebrate goodwill, family harmony and the comforting return home. Blink-182’s irreverent pop-punk number takes a rather different route. First released in the 1990s, it is a comic outburst of festive frustration rather than a cosy invitation to gather round the tree.

Not everyone loves Christmas, and some people just need to laugh at its demands. Blink-182 capture that mood with speed, sarcasm and absolutely no attempt at solemnity. A useful antidote to the endless sentimental ballads.

5. Boney M — Mary’s Boy Child / Oh My Lord

Jester Hairston wrote Mary’s Boy Child in the 1950s, and Harry Belafonte made it a major international hit. Boney M gave it an entirely new disco-era life in 1978, combining it with Oh My Lord and turning a familiar Nativity song into an irresistible seasonal production.

It is big, glossy and unmistakably of its time, but the tune is strong enough to carry the treatment. The group bring warmth and a good deal of exuberance to a song that could easily have remained a rather formal Christmas standard.

6. Boney M — O Christmas Tree

O Christmas Tree has a much longer history than most seasonal pop records. Known in German as O Tannenbaum, the song draws on an older folk tradition and became associated with Christmas trees during the nineteenth century. Its melody has travelled far beyond Germany.

Boney M take something very familiar and give it their characteristic polish. It is a gentler change of pace after the previous number and a reminder that the Christmas repertoire is not all the invention of record companies.

7. Bon Jovi — Please Come Home for Christmas

This is one of three performances of the same song in our selection, and deliberately so. Charles Brown’s original dates from 1960 and tells of loneliness during a season when everyone is supposed to be together. Bon Jovi’s later version brings the Christmas blues into the world of polished rock balladry.

Jon Bon Jovi gives it a suitably dramatic reading. It is worth comparing the approaches rather than automatically treating the loudest or most elaborate version as the best.

8. Charles Brown — Please Come Home for Christmas

Now for the song closer to its source. Blues pianist and singer Charles Brown helped write and popularise Please Come Home for Christmas in 1960. The bells and seasonal references cannot disguise its real subject: someone missing the person they love.

Brown’s understated delivery gives the number a sadness that later performers sometimes smooth away. There is nothing showy about it. That restraint is exactly what makes the song convincing. For my money, it is the version against which the others should be measured.

9. Michael Bublé — Please Come Home for Christmas

Michael Bublé’s Christmas recordings have helped keep older standards in circulation for a new audience. Here he takes on the same Charles Brown song, bringing his familiar smooth vocal style to a number rooted in rhythm and blues.

Placed after Brown and Bon Jovi, this becomes an interesting little experiment. Three singers, one song and three quite different emotional temperatures. Bublé offers warmth and elegance; listeners can decide which interpretation gets closest to the original ache.

10. Chris de Burgh — A Spaceman Came Travelling

First released in 1975, A Spaceman Came Travelling imagines the Nativity through the lens of a visitor from space. Chris de Burgh has connected its unusual premise to the ancient-astronaut ideas popularised by Erich von Däniken and to the apocalyptic imagery of W. B. Yeats. It was not an immediate UK chart triumph but gradually became a Christmas fixture.

I have always liked the way this song refuses the usual festive formula. It is mysterious and slightly otherworldly, with a memorable chorus that somehow makes science fiction and the Christmas story sit comfortably together. One of the highlights of this selection.

11. Kate Bush — December Will Be Magic Again

Kate Bush released December Will Be Magic Again in 1980. Rather than covering an established standard, she created her own winter landscape, full of strange images and dramatic changes of mood. It is not her best-known record, but it is utterly distinctive.

There are singers who sound as though they are performing a Christmas song, and then there is Kate Bush, who seems to have wandered into an entirely different world and invited us along. Beautifully eccentric and much more interesting than another predictable sleigh-bell production.

12. Mariah Carey — All I Want for Christmas Is You

Released in 1994, this has become one of the modern Christmas standards. Mariah Carey and Walter Afanasieff wrote a new song that deliberately sounded as though it belonged beside the great festive pop records of earlier decades. Its recurring chart success has made it almost impossible to escape in December.

Whether you love it or dread hearing it in every shop, its success is not an accident. The arrangement has tremendous momentum and Carey gives the vocal everything she has. It is a remarkably effective piece of pop songwriting.

13. Kelly Clarkson — Underneath the Tree

Kelly Clarkson’s Underneath the Tree appeared in 2013, from her Christmas album Wrapped in Red. Written with Greg Kurstin, it follows the great big-hearted pop tradition: prominent brass, an emphatic beat and a chorus determined to make itself heard.

This is a newer seasonal song that has earned its place alongside established favourites. Clarkson’s voice gives it real force, and it is refreshing to hear a modern Christmas number with enough confidence to stand on its own rather than simply recycle another old hit.

14. Cocteau Twins — Frosty the Snowman

Frosty the Snowman was written by Walter ‘Jack’ Rollins and Steve Nelson and became a hit for Gene Autry in 1950. Many performers have kept the cheerful story intact. The Cocteau Twins took a different route when they recorded it in the early 1990s, later including it on their Snow release.

The result is immediately recognisable yet wonderfully strange. Elizabeth Fraser’s voice seems to float above the song, while the band’s shimmering sound turns a familiar children’s favourite into something almost dreamlike. We think the Cocteau Twins can do no wrong, and this hardly weakens that case.

15. Coldplay — Christmas Lights

Coldplay released Christmas Lights in 2010. Unlike many seasonal hits, it starts from unhappiness and an attempt to find comfort amid the decorations, crowds and lights. The result is closer to a reflective pop ballad than a straightforward celebration.

Its mixture of melancholy and uplift makes a fitting conclusion. Christmas is not equally joyful for everyone, and the best songs often acknowledge that. Coldplay leave us with a little hope rather than compulsory jollity — not a bad note on which to end the first of our six specials.

A final word

That’s our first Christmas weekend song list. We will return to the regular Midweek Song List on Wednesday 18 November, with the next Christmas weekend special following on 21–22 November. There will be six in all as we head towards the big day.

In the meantime, tell us which of these versions you would keep, which you would happily never hear again, and which lesser-known Christmas records we ought to include. Until then, enjoy the music!

Leave a Comment