Click on image to buy ticket
★★★★★ Elsa McTaggart: Capturing the Light is a piece that doesn’t simply recount a family story, but reanimates a lineage of Scottish creativity, history, faith, and stubborn, rural resilience. Elsa McTaggart revisits the life of her great‑grandfather, landscape master William McTaggart, weaving faith, identity and rural Scottish heritage into a modern Fringe performance rooted in light and lineage.
What makes this production compelling is its refusal to treat William McTaggart as a museum figure. Elsa McTaggart approaches her great‑grandfather not as an icon, but as a man shaped by poverty, crofting, Gaelic culture, and the kind of hard graft that leaves its mark on every decision a person makes. The press material describes him as “the third‑born to Gaelic speaking Kintyre crofters” and someone who, through sheer determination, became “one of Scotland’s most popular and recognisable landscape artists.” That grounding matters. It frames the show not as nostalgia, but as an inquiry into how creativity emerges from constraint.
The production traces his journey from rural deprivation to the Trustees Academy School of Art in Edinburgh — a move he made at just sixteen. It’s here that he began exploring the gradations of light, a fascination that would define his work. But what the show captures beautifully is the tension between ambition and loyalty. Despite success, he stayed rooted in Scotland, loyal to the landscapes that shaped him. Many artists of his generation headed south, chasing London prestige. He didn’t. And Elsa treats that decision not as romantic mythmaking but as an act of conviction.
The spiritual dimension is where the piece becomes quietly profound. McTaggart’s upbringing in strict Presbyterianism — the kind of world where ministers scrutinise not just behaviour but intention — shaped him deeply. The show doesn’t shy away from the friction between institutional faith and personal spirituality. When the minister disapproved of his work, even visiting his Father, he didn’t abandon belief; he simply refused to let doctrine dictate his art. That moment, handled with restraint, reveals an independently minded man who saw painting not as rebellion but as devotion.
Elsa McTaggart
And this is where Elsa’s framing becomes genuinely moving. She suggests, implicitly that McTaggart’s art was a form of prayer. Not prayer as supplication, but prayer as attention — the act of looking closely at nature until it reveals something sacred. His seascapes, often devoid of figures or narrative, embody this. No ships. No drama. Just the sea as it is. The sea as he saw it. The sea as a kind of worship. He had a lifelong fascination with light; Elsa shows us why that mattered. Light, for McTaggart, wasn’t just technique. It was theology.
The show itself blends storytelling, music, and projection. Although at the show I was at technical glitches knocked out the projection forcing me to concerntrate on just the narration and music. Elsa and her long‑time collaborator Gary Lister have been performing other sold‑out Fringe shows for fifteen years, and that experience shows. The musical sections — each inspired by the titles of McTaggart’s paintings — are warm, confident, and rooted in Hebridean sensibility. The production design by Robbie Thomson gives the piece a visual clarity that mirrors McTaggart’s own obsession with light. And the involvement of Isle of Lewis arts venue An Lanntair, along with sruth‑mara’s track record of thoughtful, community‑rooted work, gives the show a sense of place that feels earned rather than decorative.
What emerges is not a biographical lecture, nor a family tribute, but a meditation on legacy — how creativity travels through generations, how rural identity shapes artistic instinct, and how faith can be both anchor and burden. Elsa isn’t simply telling us who her great‑grandfather was; she’s showing us how his way of seeing the world shaped her own.
By the end, you understand that McTaggart didn’t paint to escape his circumstances. He painted to honour them. And Elsa, in turn, honours him not by mythologising his life, but by illuminating the quiet, spiritual labour at its core.
A thoughtful, lyrical, and deeply Scottish piece of theatre — one that treats art not as spectacle, but as inheritance.
Reviewed by Pat Harrington
Leave a Reply