Click on image to buy tickets
★★★★★ A beautifully judged, musically rich, quietly emotional and gently funny exploration of Lennon & McCartney, delivered with craft, charm, and a level of musicianship that allows two men with two guitars to stand toe‑to‑toe with some of the most orchestrated recordings in pop history.
What the show is about
Sittin’ on a Cornflake is The Brothers Broke’s latest deep‑dive into the Lennon–McCartney partnership: the friendship, the rivalry, the creative tension, and the sheer musical brilliance that defined the Beatles’ most fertile years. It’s not a tribute act, nor a nostalgia show. It’s a thoughtful, musically intelligent piece of storytelling that uses the songs themselves as the narrative engine.
Tom Adams (guitar/vocals) and his twin brother Hugh (bass, harmonica, vocals) guide the audience through the arc of Lennon and McCartney’s creative relationship with warmth, humour and a distinctly Irish ease. Their rapport is relaxed and natural, and the banter — dry, lightly self‑mocking, and never forced — keeps the show grounded even as the music reaches for the big emotional notes.
What makes the show distinctive is the brothers’ focus on the game‑changing songs: the ones where Lennon and McCartney pushed ahead of everyone else, reinventing what pop music could be. They explore influence, competition, and respect — not academically, but through performance, letting the songs themselves reveal the story.
Musical handling: the heart of the show
This is where the show truly shines. The Brothers Broke take songs originally recorded with full studio orchestration and render them convincingly with just two instruments. It’s not imitation — it’s interpretation.
Tomorrow Never Knows
One of the boldest choices in the set. The original is a psychedelic studio construction built on tape loops and experimental production. Here, stripped back to acoustic essentials, the song becomes something new: stark, hypnotic, and surprisingly intimate. It’s a reminder that the Beatles’ innovations weren’t just technological — they were musical.
I Am the Walrus
Delivered raw and uncut, without the studio chaos or orchestral swirl. The performance highlights the song’s structural oddity and Lennon’s surrealism, proving that even the most layered Beatles tracks can survive — and thrive — when reduced to their bones. And I learned that it was inspired by a Lewis Carroll story!
A Day in the Life
The standout example. The original famously used a full orchestra, captured in that unforgettable film where musicians in fancy dress fall into psychedelic chaos. The Brothers Broke strip all of that away. No orchestra. No overdubs. Just two guitars — and occasionally a harmonica — yet the emotional weight remains.
They don’t attempt to replicate the orchestral swell; instead, they re‑imagine the song’s shape, leaning into its lyrical intimacy. It’s a bold choice, and it works because they understand the material at a structural level. Musical intelligence isn’t about scale — it’s about sensitivity. They know what to leave out.
Yesterday
Their use of harmonica on Yesterday is inspired. On paper, harmonica and McCartney’s most delicate ballad shouldn’t work — but it absolutely does. It adds a plaintive, folk‑like colour that freshens the song without distorting it. A respectful reinterpretation rather than reverence.
Across the set
They move confidently between Lennon‑led and McCartney‑led material, highlighting contrasts in personality and songwriting style. The choices are thoughtful, the transitions clean, and the emotional architecture of the Beatles catalogue is used to tell the story.
The brothers bring a distinctly Irish warmth to the stage. Their humour is gentle, observational, and rooted in the easy familiarity of two performers who know each other inside out. It never overshadows the music; it frames it.
Offstage, they’re exactly the same — approachable, open, and genuinely interested in conversation. That authenticity carries into the show.
Sittin’ on a Cornflake is an outstanding piece of Fringe musicianship. It’s intimate, clever, and emotionally resonant. The Brothers Broke have the rare ability to make familiar songs feel newly alive, not through gimmickry but through insight.
Two guitars. Occasional harmonica. No orchestra. No spectacle. Just two men who understand Lennon and McCartney well enough to honour them without copying them.
A superb show, and one I’d recommend without hesitation.
Reviewed by Pat Harrington
